The military raid to free the British-Irish journalist Stephen Farrell from his Taliban captors was successful in the narrowest possible sense. The rescuers got Mr Farrell out of the hands of his kidnappers in Kunduz, northern Afghanistan. But the raid should be no cause for celebration. Two Afghan civilians are said to have died in the operation. And Mr Farrell's Afghan interpreter, Sultan Munadi, was shot dead, quite possibly by Nato forces.
Much remains hazy about the raid, not least the question of who ordered it. The Ministry of Defence will only say that it was a Nato operation. But the death of a British soldier implies that UK forces were heavily involved. Whatever the truth, the rescue attempt was justified. Independent journalists on the ground in places such as Afghanistan provide a crucial service. When he was taken captive, Mr Farrell was investigating a Nato air raid from last week which appears to have resulted in appalling Afghan civilian casualties. The global public need to know the truth about such incidents and the work of journalists such as Mr Farrell are one of the few routes by which those details emerge. If such news gatherers are kidnapped, governments are surely right to make every effort to secure their release.
But methods matter and so does the human costs of such operations. The uncomfortable impression left by this raid is that Nato forces in the country value the lives of foreigners more than those of Afghans. It also emphasises the broader challenge facing Nato forces. The presence of those forces in Afghanistan might be justified, like the raid to release Mr Farrell. But the way in which they go about their task of pushing back the Taliban risks undermining the objective of stabilising the country. If ordinary Afghans turn against foreign forces because of rising civilian casualties the Nato mission will surely be doomed.
Military commanders need to learn from how this raid went wrong. The episode also underlines what the US commander in Afghanistan, Stanley McChrystal, has been saying about the importance of reducing civilian casualties and providing security for the population. The longer it takes for these lessons to be learned, the smaller the chances of success in Afghanistan become.
View all comments that have been posted about this article.
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.
The script for the period between now and the next election is already written
The factors behind the recovery up until now have been largely temporary in nature
There are solid names overdue a revival. Trevor, Colin, Keith...
1 Adrian Hamilton: Sorry, but the recession is not over
2 Leading article: Lessons from a botched raid
3 Matthew Norman: Prepare for months of dreary torture (and pass the pills)
4 Mark Lynas: Do you care about your children? Then stop flying
5 Katherine Butler: The terrible price of freedom
6 Letters: Alcohol advertising
7 Brian Viner: We Brians are an endangered species
8 The dark side of Dubai
9 'Lebanon's Madoff' bankrupted after bouncing $200,000 cheque to Hizbollah
10 Steve Connor: The story of humans unravels
1 The dark side of Dubai
2 Adrian Hamilton: Sorry, but the recession is not over
3 Brian Viner: We Brians are an endangered species
4 'Lebanon's Madoff' bankrupted after bouncing $200,000 cheque to Hizbollah
5 Brian Viner: 'When we saw a Land Rover trundling towards us, we feared the worst'
6 Michael McCarthy: The climate disaster is upon us - now
7 Letter: Tory teaser
Read Full Article »