Given the nature of the conflict in Afghanistan, a definitive, conventional "victory" is not a realistic option. Denying a sanctuary to terrorists who seek to attack the United States does not require Washington to pacify the entire country, eradicate its opium fields, or sustain a long-term military presence in Central Asia. From the sky, U.S. unmanned aerial vehicles can monitor villages, training camps, and insurgent compounds. On the ground, the United States can retain a small number of covert operatives for intelligence gathering and discrete operations against specific targets, as well as an additional small group of advisers to train Afghan police and military forces. The United States should withdraw most of its forces from Afghanistan within the next 12 to 18 months and treat al Qaeda's presence in the region as a chronic, but manageable, problem.
Washington needs to narrow its objectives to three critical tasks:
Security. Support, rather than supplant, indigenous security efforts by training and assisting the Afghan national army and police and, where appropriate, paying off or otherwise co-opting regional militias. Training should be tied to clear metrics. If those benchmarks are not achieved, Washington must cut its losses and cease further assistance. U.S. forces should not become Afghanistan's perpetual crutch.
Intelligence and Regional Relations. Sustain intelligence operations in the region through aerial surveillance, covert operations, and ongoing intelligence-sharing with the Afghan and Pakistani governments. Seek cordial relations with all of Afghanistan's neighbors, particularly Russia and Iran, as each has the means to significantly undermine or facilitate progress in the country.
Drugs. Dial back an opium eradication policy to one that solely targets drug cartels affiliated with insurgents rather than one that targets all traffickers, including poor local farmers. Harassing the latter alienates a significant portion of the rural population.
Central Asia holds little intrinsic strategic value to the United States, and America's security will not be endangered even if an oppressive regime takes over a contiguous fraction of Afghan territory. America's objective has been to neutralize the parties responsible for the atrocities committed on 9/11. The United States should not go beyond that objective by combating a regional insurgency or drifting into an open-ended occupation and nation-building mission.
Most important, Afghanistan serves as the crossroads of Central Asia. From its invasion by Genghis Khan and his two-million strong Mongol hordes to the superpower proxy war between the United States and the Soviet Union, Afghanistan's trade routes and land-locked position in the middle of the region have for centuries rendered it vulnerable to invasion by external powers. Although Afghanistan has endured successive waves of Persian, Greek, Arab, Turk, Mongol, British, and Soviet invadors, no occupying power has ever successfully conquered it. There's a reason why it has been described as the "graveyard of empires," and unless America scales down its objectives, it risks meeting a similar fate.
Download the Full White Paper (PDF) (4 MB) Get Adobe Reader Share with your friends:
Full text
Back to White Papers and Miscellaneous Reports
� 2009 The Cato InstitutePlease send comments to webmaster
Also of interest
Smart Power: Toward a Prudent Foreign Policy for America
Foreign policy expert Ted Galen Carpenter outlines strategies for protecting America's security while avoiding unnecessary and unrewarding military adventures.
Opinion and Commentary Myth v. Fact: Afghanistan Afghanistan May Be Obama's Vietnam Win, Hold and Lose The US Must Reassess Its Drone Policy A Fresh Take on Afghanistan Studies Pakistan and the Future of U.S. Policy NATO at 60: A Hollow Alliance How the Drug War in Afghanistan Undermines America's War on Terror Escaping the Trap: Why the United States Must Leave Iraq Troubled Neighbor: Mexico's Drug Violence Poses a Threat to the United States Daily Podcasts Obama's Afghanistan Strategy Advice to Obama: Afghanistan and Pakistan Obama's 'War of Necessity' Malarkey Paring Down Efforts in Pakistan and Afghanistan Lowering the Temperature in Pakistan Events The Case for Withdrawal from Afghanistan Should the United States Withdraw from Afghanistan? Afghanistan Seven Years Later Global Terror's Central Front: Pakistan and Afghanistan To Begin the World Over Again: Lawrence of Arabia from Damascus to Baghdad Central and South AsiaGeneral Strategy and U.S. Foreign Policy var gaJsHost = (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://ssl." : "http://www."); document.write(unescape("%3Cscript src='" + gaJsHost + "google-analytics.com/ga.js' type='text/javascript'%3E%3C/script%3E")); var pageTracker = _gat._getTracker("UA-1677831-1"); pageTracker._setLocalRemoteServerMode(); pageTracker._setDomainName(".cato.org"); pageTracker._setAllowLinker(true); pageTracker._setAllowHash(false); pageTracker._initData(); pageTracker._trackPageview("White Paper/Malou InnocentTed Galen Carpenter/Escaping the "Graveyard of Empires": A Strategy to Exit Afghanistan/Central and South Asia Central and South Asia General Strategy and U.S. Foreign Policy /pub_display.php?pub_id=10533"); Sign up to receive periodic updates on Cato research and publications. In addition, please add me to your bi-monthly events updates
Feeds for Cato events: RSS • iCal
Upcoming Events September 14, 2009
Should the United States Withdraw from Afghanistan?Cato Policy Forum, 12:00 pm
September 15, 2009
The Right Road for America: Top-Down Transportation Planning vs. Customer-Driven MobilityCato Policy Forum, 12:00 pm
September 17, 2009
The Supreme Court: Past and Prologue A Look at 2008 and October 2009 Terms Cato Conference, 10:30 am
September 17, 2009
Toward a Customer-Driven Transportation ReauthorizationCato Capitol Hill Briefing, 12:00 pm
September 21, 2009
Freedom and Prosperity in Central and Eastern Europe: 20 Years after the Collapse of CommunismCato Conference, 9:00 am
September 25, 2009
The Case for Withdrawal from AfghanistanCato Capitol Hill Briefing, 12:00 pm
September 30, 2009
The China Factor: Persuading Beijing to Get Tough with North KoreaCato Capitol Hill Briefing, 12:00 pm
September 30, 2009
Exit Policies for Sound Central BankingCato Conference, 12:30 pm
[ More Events ]
Sign up to receive periodic updates on Cato research and publications. In addition, please add me to your bi-monthly events updates
Feeds for Cato events: RSS • iCal
[ More Events ]
Upcoming Events
September 14, 2009Should the United States Withdraw fromAfghanistan?Cato Policy Forum, 12:00 pm
September 15, 2009The Right Road for America: Top-DownTransportation Planning vs. Customer-DrivenMobilityCato Policy Forum, 12:00 pm
September 17, 2009The Supreme Court: Past and Prologue A Look at2008 and October 2009 Terms Cato Conference, 10:30 am
September 17, 2009Toward a Customer-Driven TransportationReauthorizationCato Capitol Hill Briefing, 12:00 pm
September 21, 2009Freedom and Prosperity in Central and EasternEurope: 20 Years after the Collapse of CommunismCato Conference, 9:00 am
September 25, 2009The Case for Withdrawal from AfghanistanCato Capitol Hill Briefing, 12:00 pm
Cato Institute • 1000 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W. • Washington D.C. 20001-5403 Phone (202) 842-0200 • Fax (202) 842-3490
Full text
Back to White Papers and Miscellaneous Reports
� 2009 The Cato InstitutePlease send comments to webmaster
Smart Power: Toward a Prudent Foreign Policy for America
Foreign policy expert Ted Galen Carpenter outlines strategies for protecting America's security while avoiding unnecessary and unrewarding military adventures.
Printer Friendly Version
Feeds for Cato events: RSS • iCal
Should the United States Withdraw from Afghanistan?Cato Policy Forum, 12:00 pm
The Right Road for America: Top-Down Transportation Planning vs. Customer-Driven MobilityCato Policy Forum, 12:00 pm
The Supreme Court: Past and Prologue A Look at 2008 and October 2009 Terms Cato Conference, 10:30 am
Toward a Customer-Driven Transportation ReauthorizationCato Capitol Hill Briefing, 12:00 pm
Freedom and Prosperity in Central and Eastern Europe: 20 Years after the Collapse of CommunismCato Conference, 9:00 am
The Case for Withdrawal from AfghanistanCato Capitol Hill Briefing, 12:00 pm
The China Factor: Persuading Beijing to Get Tough with North KoreaCato Capitol Hill Briefing, 12:00 pm
Exit Policies for Sound Central BankingCato Conference, 12:30 pm
[ More Events ]
Feeds for Cato events: RSS • iCal
[ More Events ]
Read Full Article »