October 7, 2009

Iran Is Not Stalinist Russia

Michael Totten, Commentary Magazine

AP Photo

In the October 12 issue of Newsweek, Fareed Zakaria makes a case for containing rather than confronting Iran, partly because he expects “a massive outpouring of support for the Iranian regime” if its nuclear-weapons facilities are attacked by the U.S. or Israel. “This happens routinely when a country is attacked by foreign forces, no matter how unpopular the government,” he writes.

As a precedent, he cites how Russians rallied to Stalin when Germany invaded in 1941. But of course Russians rallied to Stalin. No viable political opposition existed as it does today in Iran, and besides: they were attacked by the Nazis. The Germans weren’t liberators. Russia was not going to be treated better by foreign totalitarians than by its own. Even the...

Read Full Article ››

TAGGED: Hezbollah, Lebanon, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, Ali Khamenei, Fareed Zakaria, Iran

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

May 10, 2012
Can Mighty Israel Make Peace?
Shmuel Rosner, Rosner's Domain
When someone like Fareed Zakaria compliments someone like Binyamin Netanyahu one knows trouble is coming. more ››
May 17, 2012
Iran Must Choose Enmity or Economy
Ray Takeyh, Financial Times
Diplomacy is reclaiming a role in Iran's nuclear drama, but little attention is being paid to a conflict of interests that is likely to complicate Tehran's path to a settlement. The objectives of the western powers are clear:... more ››
May 11, 2012
Israeli Attack on Iran May Enrage Muslim World
Ahmed Rashid, Haaretz
Iran is far more likely to mobilize on the basis of the much wider support it can muster in the Muslim world, which is already seething with anti-American and anti-Israeli feelings. more ››
May 11, 2012
Prepare for the Long Haul in Syria
Michael Young, Daily Star
One thing that the Lebanese can usually do with some precision is predict stalemate. Their own conflict between 1975 and 1990 was one long, debilitating lesson in destructive deadlock. So when those in Beirut look toward Syria... more ››
May 16, 2012
The Risks of a Syria Spillover
Andrew Exum, World Politics Review
Over the past week, we have seen the first real case of sectarian violence spilling over from Syria into neighboring Lebanon. In clashes in and around the northern Lebanese city of Tripoli, at least five people have been killed... more ››