So Much for Russia the Energy Superpower

So Much for Russia the Energy Superpower

Five years ago, when oil prices were climbing steadily and economists were stoking fears about peak oil and gas, it seemed that major energy producers like Russia were holding all the cards. Then-president Vladimir Putin spoke of his country as an "energy superpower" and used energy supplies as a blunt instrument of Kremlin foreign policy. Gas cutoffs to Ukraine caused panic in Europe, while Western energy companies fell over each other to get a slice of Russia's oil and gas fields.

But all that is over. Today, the super-giant Shtockmann natural-gas field under the Arctic sea"”Russia's only big hydrocarbon discovery since Soviet times"”has just been mothballed due to the towering cost of extracting the undersea gas. At the same time, worldwide demand for Russia's gas has plummeted. And meanwhile, the government has punctured investor confidence by pressuring BP, one of the few major foreign investors left in Russia's energy sector, to hand over a giant Siberian gas field to a government-owned rival. It's time for Moscow to kiss goodbye those dreams of energy hegemony.


One problem is that the recession has eviscerated European demand for Russian natural gas (consumption dipped by 7 percent in 2009). Another is that demand in the United States for imported natural gas has fallen off too. Thanks to shale gas and other unconventional sources like tar sands, the U.S. is now close to self-sufficient in natural gas. It's a nightmare for Shtockmann, where the business plan hinged on freezing the product into liquified natural gas, or LNG, for export to the United States.

That made the Shtockmann field, with reserves of 3.7 trillion cubic meters, seem less like the strategic future of Russian natural gas and more like an M&M that fell behind the couch"”tasty, but not strictly necessary and very hard to reach. The $20 billion cost of extracting the deep-buried gas in the harsh conditions of the Arctic has proved prohibitive for Gazprom and its minority partners, Total of France and Statoil of Norway.

That's a problem for Gazprom, which was the main cudgel of Putin's foreign policy just four years ago, when he played one European country against another in their eagerness to lay Gazprom pipelines across their territory. Now the European market seems oversupplied. More worrying still, Gazprom's traditional suppliers (gas fields in the Central Asian nations of Turkmenistan and Kazakhstan) have begun opening their own direct pipelines to China, where gas consumption has a future. And though Gazprom still controls about 17 percent of the world's proven natural-gas reserves, many of its existing fields are beginning to run dry. Getting at the remainder"”for instance at the Bovanenkovo field in the remote Yamal Peninsula in Siberia"”will need massive investment of cash and know-how. Who wants to sink in that kind of money with no guarantee of returns?

That's why the latest attack on BP is so strange"”and so dumb. A time of falling demand, unstable energy prices, and investor nervousness about emerging markets might seem like a bad moment to crack down on one of the few large foreign investors in Russia's energy sector. But that hasn't stopped Russia's Natural Environment Inspectorate, or RosPrirodNadzor, from threatening to throw BP off the giant Kovykta gas field in Eastern Siberia. The official reason for the threat is alleged environmental infractions"”the same reasons cited by the Russian state when Royal Dutch Shell was persuaded to sell Gazprom its stake in an oilfield in Sakhalin two years ago for below market value. But the real reason seems to be that the state oil company Rosneft has its eye on BP's field.


This is hardly the first time Russia's government has shaken down BP"”or other investors. In 2007 the Russian Natural Resources Ministry threatened to tear up the Kovykta contract because of alleged violations of the exploration timetable. Then, the predator was Gazprom, which wanted Kovykta for a knockdown price and was also at the time hustling to get a slice of a BP gas project in Trinidad and Tobago. That deal stalled on legal wrangling and was ultimately sunk by the 2008 economic crisis, which reduced Gazprom's voracious appetite for expansion. But now, it seems, Rosneft is taking up where Gazprom left off"”and in the process reminding investors in all sectors of the dangers of doing business in Russia. The difference is, of course, that in 2007 energy prices were rising and plentiful investment money was wandering the world, desperately seeking high returns whatever the risk. Today, the opposite is true. "It is not just a big gas field at stake here. It is about the country's entire investment climate," says Valery Nesterov, an oil and gas analyst from Troika Dialog brokerage. "Russia has to attract foreigners to develop Yamal and offshore fields."

Russia remains the largest exporter of oil and gas in the world"”bigger even than Saudi Arabia. But unlike the Gulf nations, Russia is fast pumping its existing wells of both oil and gas dry. To tap its reserves"”and to maintain Russia's status as an "energy superpower""”Russia needs to stop ripping off its investors just because a demand falloff has hurt its bottom line. Gas consumption will come back. But Russia's superpower aspirations won't also rise if Russia has alienated its partners. Without them, its new reserves"”like the Shtockmann field"”will remain buried in the ground.

© 2010

var OutbrainPermaLink = "" + masterPageId; var OB_Template = "newsweek"; var OB_demoMode = false; var OBITm = "1254773538724"; var OB_langJS =''; if ( typeof(OB_Script)!='undefined' ) OutbrainStart(); else { var OB_Script = true; } Share: Facebook Digg Tweet LinkedIn newsweek: Tools: 7 Post Your Comment Print Email NWK.widget.EmailArticle.init(); SPONSORED BY placeAd2('printthis','88x31|3',false,''); placeAd2(commercialNode,'below_story',false,'') var url = ''; url += '?CommercialNode=' + commercialNode; // NOTE :: The "scr" + "ipt" break is essential, presumably to bypass loose // js/DOM safeguards against doing what we want to do here. document.write('"); var isAuthenticated = false; Discuss Enter Your Comment NWK.widget.CommentsSubmit.form = $('#comment-form'); NWK.widget.CommentsSubmit.init(); placeAd2('comments/'+commercialNode,'88x31|2',false,''); Sponsored by Member Comments Reply Report Abuse Posted By: etim @ 02/25/2010 5:28:42 AM

Dear Owen, if you write an article as an expert in energy issues, along with checking the facts, please bother checking the spelling - the official name of the Arctic gas field is Shtokman, not Shtockmann. Agree with the previous comment, very short-sighted and lop-sided article.

Reply Report Abuse Posted By: 5par7acu5 @ 02/25/2010 5:20:02 AM

"Thanks to shale gas and other unconventional sources like tar sands, the U.S. is now close to self-sufficient in natural gas." Wrong. Shale gas is still science fiction and at present uneconomical (price of natgas is way too low). Tar sands produces heavy oil and requires natgas as input.

Reply Report Abuse Posted By: PGelsman @ 02/25/2010 3:48:40 AM

Too bad!

Reply Enter Your Comment Report Abuse

Enter comments if any for reporting abuse

Report Abuse View All Comments » NWK.widget.CommentsReply.init(); NWK.widget.CommentsReport.init(); placeAd2(commercialNode,'articleFlex',false,'') var flashvars = {}; var params = {}; var attributes = {}; params.allowScriptAccess = "always"; params.wmode = "transparent"; = "World"; flashvars.nw = "t"; flashvars.env = "prod"; flashvars.omnitureAccount = "wpninewsweekprod"; flashvars.pageType = "SP"; flashvars.fileLoc = ""; if (hasFlash("swfTopTenVertical")) swfobject.embedSWF("", "swfTopTenVertical", "331", "220", "8.0.0", "", flashvars, params, attributes); var url = ''; url += '?CommercialNode=c_col_' + commercialNode; // NOTE :: The "scr" + "ipt" break is essential, presumably to bypass loose // js/DOM safeguards against doing what we want to do here. document.write('"); #container2 { margin-top: 10px; border-top:2px solid #999; width:350px; font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif; background-image: url(; background-repeat: repeat-x; } #container2 img { border:none; float:right; } .digg { margin:0 0 30px 5px; overflow:hidden; padding-left: 5px; } .digg h3 { font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif!important; color:#000; font-size:14px!important; padding:12px 0 12px 0; text-transform:uppercase; } .diggs { color:#336599; float:left; height:30px; line-height:30px; margin-left:10px; padding-right:10px; width:32px; } .digg-article { border-bottom:1px solid #999; overflow:hidden; padding-bottom:7px; } .digg ul { overflow:hidden; padding-bottom:9px; padding-top:14px; list-style:none; } .digg ul li { clear:left; overflow:hidden; padding:8px 0 0; } .digg ul li img { padding-right:6px; } .digg .text { float:left; font-size:1.2em; line-height:1.25; padding-bottom:5px; width:200px; } .digg-count { background-image: url(!important; background-repeat:no-repeat!important; background-position:left !important; float:left; color:#000 !important; height:30px; line-height:30px; margin-right:0 !important; padding-right:10px; text-decoration:none !important; width:32px; font-size:11px!important; text-align:center !important; } .digg-ajax h3 a { color:#900 !important; font-size:12px !important; line-height:16px !important; text-decoration:none !important; text-transform:none !important; vertical-align:center !important; } .digg-ajax h3 a:hover { text-decoration:underline!important; } .digg-ajax ul { padding-bottom:2px !important; padding-top:0 !important; } .digg-ajax li { border-top:1px solid #ccc; padding:8px 0 !important; } .digg-ajax li a span { display:none !important; } .digg-footer { border-top: 1px solid #ccc; padding-top:8px; width: 330px; } Newsweek on Digg digg_id = 'digg-widget-container'; //make this id unique for each widget you put on a single page. digg_width = '330px'; digg_height = 'auto'; digg_border = 0; digg_theme = 'digg-widget-unstyled'; digg_title = 'Popular stories from the source site sorted by dates'; var config = new Object(); config["divid"] = "brightcove30256"; config["type"] = "mini_standard"; config["configpid"] = "1243489057"; config["rsspid"] = "1137883278"; config["rsslid"] = "1137849353"; config["numItems"] = "5"; config["lineupCollapse"] = "true"; config["lineupName"] = "MORE VIDEO"; config["videoPreview"] = "false"; config["autoStart"] = "false"; config["width"] = 336; config["height"] = 390; config["styleclass"] = "brightcove-mini-player"; config["activeTab"] = "video"; config["bgColor"] = "#FFFFFF"; config["url"] = "30256"; if (typeof(commercialNode) != 'undefined') config["commercialNode"] = commercialNode; if (typeof(commercialNode) != 'undefined') placeAd2("video/"+commercialNode,'video',false,''); bcFullscreenPlayer(config); Previous Next   02/16 - 02/22 News/Week The Keys to Success for CEO Politicians 3 Reasons Americans Support Letting Gays Serve When Should We Use the "�Terrorist' Label? NEWSWEEK Poll: Mixed Signals on Health Care My Turn: Why We Need More Lobbyists Terror Begins with Fearmongering Politicians Who in the Taliban Will Replace Baradar? How China Is Good for Tibet UK Authorities Summon Israeli Envoy in Dubai Hit-Team Probe Wall Street's Euro Scams Gauging the Stimulus in One Neighborhood We Read It: Henry Paulson's "�On the Brink' We Read It: "�The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks' TV Review: "�How to Make It in America' John Mayer's Racism Shared by Others in Power Why Racial Disparities in Health Care Persist Enviro Group Hits Back at Climate Skeptics Newsweek Rumblr: Tiger Woods Apology Edition NWK.widget.NewsSlashWeek.init(); placeAd2(commercialNode,'rightSidePromo',false,'') U.S. general hails historic day in Marjah Compromise unlikely at health summit "�Thrashing' orca drowned SeaWorld trainer Famed X-Games skier dies after fall Northeast braces for second storm Democrats looking past summit to final talks Poll: Many see a China century President may bend on agency Contrite Toyota chief faces ire Looking outside the race box Slate V: How to Judge the Best Sound Editing Oscar Why the GOP's current brand of hypocrisy is worse than the Democrats'. A glossary of words, phrases, and slogans to be uttered at the televised White House health summit. Does NATO belong in Afghanistan? The Slatest: Evening Edition Five Scenarios for Obama's Health Care Summit Toyota Chief Tells Lawmakers He Takes 'Full Responsibility' France Fuming Over Scandalous Anti-Smoking Ads Israeli Intelligence Burnishes Image at Expense of Hamas Dutch Convict Pulls Off 'Shawshank'-Like Breakout Mr. Toyoda Regrets App-etizers Feb. 24: Is Bing the iPad's Default Search Engine? Can Texts Inspire Literature? Schools Are Primed for the iPad California Agents Crack Down on "Infused" Booze Airfare sale! Half off flights San Francisco: Decoding wine tastings The airlines and a la carte passenger anger London: A side trip to Hadrian's Wall London: In search of Sherlock Holmes About NewsweekAdvertising InformationSubscriber ServicesPressroomContact UsUser AgreementPrivacy PolicyJobsBack CopiesRights and Reprint SalesShowcase AdsSitemap© 2010 Newsweek, Inc.

Read Full Article »
Show commentsHide Comments

Related Articles