Obama Repeats Bush's Mistake in Russia

Obama Repeats Bush's Mistake in Russia

Still in the midst of a diplomatic fracas with Israel, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton also found herself in a mini-crisis with Russia during last week's Moscow trip. Prime Minister Vladimir Putin publicly snubbed Clinton during a meeting Friday, hectoring her in front of reporters after announcing Thursday that Russia would bring the nuclear reactor it is constructing in Iran online later this year. This comes just as Washington is hoping to tighten the screws on Tehran over its illicit nuclear program.

Putin's treatment of Clinton raises doubts about the Barack Obama administration's strategy toward Russia, which has focused on building up the supposedly moderate President Dmitri Medvedev, reportedly one of the few foreign leaders Obama has bonded with, as a counterweight to Putin.

Obama's focus on a personal relationship with a Russian leader is nothing new; in fact it's drearily consistent with how past U.S. presidents have handled their relations with Russia. After his first meeting with then-President Putin in June 2001, George W. Bush famously said: "I looked the man in the eye. I was able to get a sense of his soul." But despite some early agreements between the two leaders that enabled the United States to withdraw from the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty and cooperate in Central Asia in the aftermath of the 9/11 terrorist attacks, by the end of Bush's second term relations with Russia had appreciably worsened and Russian democracy was in full retreat.

Bush's focus on his personal relationship with the thuggish Putin was rightly scorned. But Bush was not the first American president to place a bet on personal ties between himself and a leader in Moscow. As the Soviet Union was coming to an end, George H. W. Bush clearly preferred doing business with its no-nonsense leader, Mikhail Gorbachev, to the disheveled, vodka-loving Boris Yeltsin. But Gorbachev's agenda was about saving the Soviet Union, while Yeltsin, for all his flaws, wanted to bury that corpse and move Russia toward the West and democratic rule. And now, we're hearing that Obama believes he has a different and promising relationship with Medvedev -- one independent of Putin.

Medvedev, to be sure, talks a different game than Putin. On the domestic front, he has spoken and written extensively about the need to liberalize Russia's politics and economy, tackle corruption, and unwind the worst features of the autocratic and oligarchic system now in place. And it is on this basis that Obama's efforts to build a solid personal relationship with Medvedev can be justified. Or can they?

For all his talk of reform -- and so far it is just that, talk -- Medvedev still claims that Russia is a working democracy that protects the liberties of individual Russians despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary. And on the national security front, it is difficult to see much light between Medvedev and Putin if Medvedev is judged by his actions, not just his rhetoric. Since becoming Putin's hand-picked successor as president in May 2008, Medvedev has done little to blunt his predecessor's Russian revanchist policies. On Medvedev's watch, Georgia has been invaded and Abkhazia and South Ossetia effectively annexed, and Russia has continued to threaten its neighbors and put forward a "new security architecture" whose obvious goal is to undermine NATO's role in Europe.

12NEXT Save big when you subscribe to FP.

JEWEL SAMAD/AFP/Getty Images

 

Jamie M. Fly is executive director of the Foreign Policy Initiative. Gary Schmitt is director of the Program on Advanced Strategic Studies at the American Enterprise Institute.

The World Loves Elephants MoreThan Whales

How Chinese Tech Companies Went Global

Egypt's Spinster Epidemic

British Envoy: Iran Is Getting Weaker

HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE

PATSURFS

10:14 PM ET

March 22, 2010

Just say it:

Russia doesn't need the U.S., the U.S. needs Russia.

GREGO

12:57 AM ET

March 23, 2010

Unfortunately Medvedev seems

Unfortunately Medvedev seems to be a muppet in Putin's hand, I hope Obama won't spend too much time listening to his words that will never become acts...

annuaire

ALEXF

5:32 AM ET

March 23, 2010

>>And on the national security front, it is difficult to see muc

Oh, I wish it was true.. I hope we will really strengthen our army and navy - these sole Russia's allies..

MOSTREAD

MOSTCOMMENTED

Read Full Article »
Comment
Show commentsHide Comments

Related Articles