Why the Pope Must Step Down

Why the Pope Must Step Down

What's fascinating in the steady onslaught of new incidences of previous cover-ups of child rape and molestation in the Catholic hierarchy is the notion that the hierarchs tended to see child rape as a sin rather than a crime. Hence the emphasis on forgiveness, therapy, repentance - rather than removal, prosecution and investigation. Obviously, there's one reason for this: they were defending the reputation of the church by hiding its darkest secrets, and they were using the authority of religion to do so. But I suspect it's also true that this is how they genuinely thought of child rape or abuse.

How could that be, one asks? Well: imagine you are a young gay Catholic teen coming into his sexuality and utterly convinced that it's vile and evil. What do you do? I can tell you from my own experience. You bury it. But of course, you can't bury it. So you objectify sex; and masturbate. You cannot have sexual or even emotional contact with a teenage girl, because it is simply impossible, and you certainly cannot have sex with another teenage boy or you will burn in hell for ever ... so you have sex with images in your own head. Your sex life becomes completely solitary. It can be empowered by pornography or simply teenage imagination. Some shard of beauty, some aspect of sensuality, some vision of desire will keep you sexually energized for days.

Now suppose your powers of suppression and attachment to religious authority are also strong - perhaps stronger because you feel so adrift you need something solid to cling onto in your psyche. And you know you cannot marry a woman. But you want to have status and cover as a single man. If this is the 1950s and 1960s, it's into the Church you go. You think it will cure you. In fact, it only makes you sicker because your denial is buttressed by their collective denial. And the whole thing becomes one big and deepening spiral of lies and corruption.

 

Many of these tormented men have arrested sexual and emotional development. They have never had a sexual or intimate relationship with any other human being. Sex for them is an abstraction, a sin, not an interaction with an equal. And their sexuality has been frozen at the first real moment of internal terror: their early teens. So they tend to be attracted still to those who are in their own stage of development: teenage boys. And in their new positions, they are given total access to these kids who revere them for their power.

So they use these children to express themselves sexually. They barely see these children as young and vulnerable human beings, incapable of true consent. Because they have never had a real sexual relationship, have never had to deal with the core issue of human equality and dignity in sex, they don't see the children as victims. Like the tortured gay man, Michael Jackson, they see them as friends. They are even gifted at interacting with them in non-sexual ways. One theme you find in many of these stories is that until these screwed up priests' abuse and molestation is revealed, they often have a great reputation as pastors. As emotionally developed as your average fourteen year old wanting to be loved, they sublimate a lot of their lives into clerical service. But they also act out sexually all the time.

And they know that many around them have the same patterns, and so a truly sick subculture perpetuates this. In the end, it is all about themselves and their pathologies, how to express them and how to hide them. As social sexual tolerance advances, and as fewer straight men are prepared to give up sex for life to become priests, the proportion of screwed up pastors increases. In this self-protective environment, these priests do not even see the children as fellow humans. They remain like those solitary abstract images in their heads. So they cannot fully grasp the enormity of the crime they are committing and see it merely as another part of the vortex of their sexual sin.

So they cover up for one another; they fear that if one of them falls, they will all fall; even those who are not totally screwed up about sex are eager to prevent the church's secret from being exposed. But the more they cover up, the bigger the calamity when it all emerges. And when it's clear that at the center of this kind of pathological secrecy and shame is the current Pope, then it is clear that the entire institution is corrupt from the top down.

These men are too objectively disordered to run a church. They bask in self-denial, while they wage a culture war against gay men who have actually dealt with their sexuality, who have owned it, and celebrated it and even found ways to channel it into adult relationships and even civil marriage.

We all know this game is now over. The current Pope is now found directly responsible for two clear incidents of covering up or ignoring child abuse and rape. As head of the organization that took responsibility for investigating these cases for so long, his complicity in this vast and twisted criminal conspiracy is not in dispute. If he were the head of a secular organization, he would have already resigned and be cooperating with the police.

But he is the Vicar of Christ on earth.

It's hard to imagine a deeper crisis for the Catholic hierarchy than this. If the church is to survive - and it will because it is the vessel of eternal truth - it will have to go through a wrenching transformation.

Beginning with the resignation of this Pope and an end to priestly celibacy.

 

TrackBack URL for this entry:

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c45669e201310fdcfc62970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference 'Sin Or Crime?'

atmoAds.displayAtlanticAd('topboxright','0x0');

 

atlanticPrintmodulesvoicesMenu(); Voices

Atlantic Voices and Correspondents

atlanticPrintmoduleswireFeed(); The Atlantic Wire Sully's Recent Keepers Sin Or Crime?

Many of these tormented priests have arrested development.

Obama's Victory Of Persistence

HCR will also empower him abroad.

Under The Microscope

TNC's commenters have been discussing my 'conservatism.'

The Current Vatican's Death Throes

What is happening in Germany happened in Boston.

The Death Of Conservatism, Ctd

The chattering classes are declaring its rebirth.

atlanticPrintauthormagazineContent(); Andrew Sullivan from the Magazine Read Andrew Sullivan in TheAtlantic magazine Masthead “ To see what is in front of one's nose needs a constant struggle”

"” George Orwell

E-Mail Andrew | Bio

Dish Prep

Patrick Appel Chris Bodenner

An Award Glossary The View From Your Window Add this RSS Feed  Site Meter  Books The View from Your Window:The World as Seen by the Readers of One Blog The Conservative Soul:Fundamentalism, Freedom, and the Future of the Right View:

Virtually Normal:An Argument About Homosexuality

Love Undetectable:Notes on Friendship, Sex and Survival

Same-Sex Marriage: Pro and Con, A Reader

Intimations Pursued: The Voice of Practice in the Conversation of Michael Oakeshott

Daily Read Drudge Report Washington Post New York Times The Onion Instapundit The Corner The Plank Talking Points Memo Slate The Daily Telegraph The Times The Guardian Daily Kos Washington Monthly The Weekly Standard Hit & Run The Volokh Conspiracy Michelle Malkin Hugh Hewitt Glenn Greenwald Juan Cole The Huffington Post Matt Yglesias The Spine YouTube Washington Ind. Balkinization Memeorandum Dan Drezner The Daily Beast Belgravia Dispatch Ind. Gay Forum Blog Love 2Blowhards 3 Quarks Daily The American Scene Ann Althouse Bryan Appleyard Attackerman Ryan Avent Baghdad Bureau Stephen Bainbridge Balloon Juice Thomas P.M. Barnett The Baseline Scenario Becker And Posner Blog Jonathan Bernstein The Big Picture Bookforum Books Inq Bookslut Booksquare Box Turtle Bulletin Ed Brayton Christopher Buckley Buzzfeed Calculated Risk Capital Gains & Games Nicholas Carr Steve Coll Commonweal Contentions Chris Crain Crooked Timber The Cunning Realist Clive Davis Danger Room The Daily What Democracy Arsenal Democracy In America Ross Douthat Rod Dreher Kevin Drum Economix Enduring America Eschaton Everything Is Terrible Justin Fox Austin Frakt Free Exchange The Field FiveThirtyEight The Frontal Cortex Global Voices Gristmill Hendrik Hertzberg Scott Horton Rob Horning Human Nature More Intelligent Life Kenyon Review Ezra Klein Kottke David Kuo Daniel Larison The Lede Damon Linker Marc Lynch Majikthise Michael Mandel Irshad Manji Greg Mankiw Marginal Revolution Alex Massie Mind Hacks The Moderate Voice Abu Muqawama Nerdcore New Majority The Next Right NIAC Nige atmoAds.displayAtlanticAd('halfbox','300x125');

 

Subscribe Help Faq Follow the Atlantic Masthead Store Jobs Educational Program Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Advertise Contact Us Copyright © todaysDate();2010 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All Rights Reserved. _qoptions={ qacct:"p-b0K-eQJGBXxXE" }; Skip this ad - atmoAds.displayAtlanticAd('welcome','0x0');

 

_qoptions = { tags:"typepad.extended" }; _qacct="p-fcYWUmj5YbYKM"; quantserve(); function TYPEPAD___getTop() { return document.documentElement.scrollTop; } function TYPEPAD___getLeft() { return document.documentElement.scrollLeft; } var TYPEPAD___b = document.body; var TYPEPAD___bookmarklet_domain='http://www.typepad.com/'; var TYPEPAD___loader = new YAHOO.util.YUILoader(); var TYPEPAD___msgResponses = { blogIt: function() { window.focus(); // can't grab the selection when the focus is still on the toolbar if(TYPEPAD___b&&!document.xmlVersion){void(z=document.createElement('script'));void(z.type='text/javascript');void(TYPEPAD___b.appendChild(z));void(z.src='http://static.typepad.com/.shared/js/qp/loader-combined-min.js');}else{} }, showToolbar: function() { YAHOO.util.Dom.setStyle( 'typepad_controls', 'display', '' ); }, scrollDown: function() { /* Fire this in case the showToolbar message got lost on page load (IE) */ this.showToolbar(); YAHOO.util.Dom.setStyle( 'typepad_controls', 'width', '100%' ); var bodyanim = new YAHOO.util.Anim( document.body, { top: { to: '29' } }, .3, YAHOO.util.Easing.easeBoth ); bodyanim.onComplete.subscribe( function() { YAHOO.util.Dom.setStyle( 'typepad_controls', 'height', '44px' ); } ); bodyanim.animate(); }, scrollUp: function() { var bodyanim = new YAHOO.util.Anim( document.body, { top: { to: '0' } }, .3, YAHOO.util.Easing.easeBoth ); bodyanim.onStart.subscribe( function() { YAHOO.util.Dom.setStyle( 'typepad_controls', 'height', '66px'); } ); bodyanim.onComplete.subscribe( function() { YAHOO.util.Dom.setStyle( 'typepad_controls', 'width', '45px' ); } ); bodyanim.animate(); }, favorite: function() { this.sendMsg( 'favorite', 'favbutton-6a00d83451c45669e201310fdcfc62970c' ); }, unfavorite: function() { this.sendMsg( 'unfavorite', 'favbutton-6a00d83451c45669e201310fdcfc62970c' ); }, favoriteTB: function() { this.sendMsg( 'favorite', 'typepad_controls' ); }, unfavoriteTB: function() { this.sendMsg( 'unfavorite', 'typepad_controls' ); }, follow: function() { this.sendMsg( 'follow', 'follow-button-frame' ); }, unfollow: function() { this.sendMsg( 'unfollow', 'follow-button-frame' ); }, followTB: function() { this.sendMsg( 'follow', 'typepad_controls' ); }, unfollowTB: function() { this.sendMsg( 'unfollow', 'typepad_controls' ); }, /* Recreate crossTalk.sendMessage to reduce external JS calls */ sendMsg: function(msg, target) { var frame, origin; frame = window.frames[target]; origin = document.getElementById(target).src; if( window.postMessage && frame ) frame.postMessage(msg, origin); else if( frame ) { frame.location = origin + '#' + msg; } else { // Missing frame, can't do anything } } }; /* Set body position to relative */ TYPEPAD___b.style.position = "relative"; TYPEPAD___loader.require("yahoo-dom-event", "animation"); TYPEPAD___loader.onSuccess = function() { /* Recreate crossTalk.receiveMessage to reduce external JS calls */ if( window.postMessage ) { YAHOO.util.Event.on( window, "message", function(e) { if( TYPEPAD___msgResponses[e.data] ) TYPEPAD___msgResponses[e.data](); }); } else { var x = setInterval( function() { var hash = document.location.hash; hash = hash.substring(1,hash.length); if( hash && hash != "tp" ) { /* Only reset hash and call response if we recognize it */ if( TYPEPAD___msgResponses[hash] ) { /* Reset hash to a non zero value to prevent IE from jumping back to the top of the page */ document.location.hash = "#tp"; TYPEPAD___msgResponses[hash](); } } }, 200 ); } /* If the blog has a margin on the body we need to tweak the position of the toolbar */ var bodyMargin = parseInt(YAHOO.util.Dom.getStyle( document.body, 'margin-top' )); var toolbarTop = parseInt(YAHOO.util.Dom.getStyle( 'typepad_controls', 'top' )); var newTop = (toolbarTop - bodyMargin) + "px"; YAHOO.util.Dom.setStyle( 'typepad_controls', 'top', newTop ); }; TYPEPAD___loader.insert();

http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c45669e201310fdcfc62970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference 'Sin Or Crime?'

 

Atlantic Voices and Correspondents

Many of these tormented priests have arrested development.

HCR will also empower him abroad.

TNC's commenters have been discussing my 'conservatism.'

What is happening in Germany happened in Boston.

The chattering classes are declaring its rebirth.

"” George Orwell

Read Full Article »
Comment
Show commentsHide Comments

Related Articles