Is Libya Like Kosovo? Let's Hope So

Is Libya Like Kosovo? Let's Hope So

It is worth noting, four days into the air campaign against Libya, that we are just four days into the air campaign against Libya.

On cable news, four days seems an eternity. Hence the vein-popping impatience for Qaddafi to crumble, the outrage that Obama isn't doing something more quickly (just what isn't quite clear), the heaving sighs over the coalition's failure (after hours of meetings) to work out the precise procedures of command and control.

Yet as several Pentagon officials cautioned at the outset of this crisis, these things are complicated; they require coordination, which takes time. This fact of course inspired some of the more enthusiastic hawks to urge Obama to take action unilaterally"”which might have been speedier in the short run but a disaster in the end.

The hand-wringing from all sides is reminiscent of NATO's 1999 air war against Serbia, which was mounted to protect Kosovar citizens from the savagery of Slobodan Milosevic. President Bill Clinton's decision to intervene in that internal war came at a much later point in the conflict than Barack Obama's, after the dictator had inflicted far greater damage. Clinton sidestepped the U.N. Security Council knowing that Russia and China would veto a resolution, but he did go through the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, whose member-states saw the campaign"”the first time they'd waged war together in NATO's half-century history"”as a test of the alliance's continued relevance in the post-Cold War era.

Clinton was hammered from liberals and conservatives for taking this multilateral approach, which they derided as "war by committee." In his 2001 book Waging Modern War, Gen. Wesley Clark, who ran the air campaign as Supreme Allied Commander Europe, detailed the frustrations of fighting an alliance war"”the endless squabbles over tactics, strategy, even which targets to strike.

Yet, Clark concluded, the results"”an enduring victory, with Milosevic ousted and put on trial, the alliance renewed, and a postwar peacekeeping deployment that (however flawed) stopped the violence and sparked virtually no coalition casualties"”could not have been achieved through a more "efficient" unilateral operation.

Clark made many mistakes during the campaign, not least in his expectation"”which he voiced publicly"”that Milosevic would surrender after a mere three days. In fact, the bombing went on for 11 weeks"”as did the seething political attacks on Clinton (and Clark) for embarking on the scheme to begin with.

Who can say how long the air war over Libya will last, how fiercely it might escalate, or"”this is the big question"”what happens afterward?

President Obama has said that the operation's current phase will last "days, not weeks," but by this he means the phase at which U.S. forces continue to play the dominant role. (He didn't make this point clearly enough, and so, after the war goes on for two weeks, as it almost certainly will, watch for the news shows to play that clip over and over as putative proof of Obama's naiveté or deception.)

Some have scoffed at Obama's claim that this is a multilateral campaign, noting that, on the first day, the United States fired 124 Tomahawk cruise missiles, while the British fired just two.

But sometimes public statements should be taken at face value. When a no-fly zone was first proposed, Secretary of Defense Robert Gates warned that it would have to be preceded by an attack on Libya's air-defense systems so that coalition pilots could then patrol the skies with minimal fear of getting shot down. At the start of the campaign, President Obama said that U.S. forces had "unique capabilities" that can clear the way for allied aircraft to enforce the U.N. resolution.

That is what the first day's barrage was all about. Those "unique capabilities" consisted of long-range weapons that can hit targets, such as air-defense batteries, with precision"”namely, the Tomahawk cruise missiles, launched from four ships off Libya's coast, and a number of Joint Direct Attack Munitions fired from three B-52 bombers. No other country could have amassed that much accurate firepower in such concentrated salvos.

Now, as a result, Libya's air defenses are pretty much obliterated, and the other countries' air forces can patrol the area"”and, in some cases, bomb and strafe Qaddafi's ground forces, as some already have"”with relative impunity.

Become a fan of Slate on Facebook. Follow Slate and the Slate Foreign Desk on Twitter.

TodaysMedia.init(); GET TODAY IN SLATE Sign up for Slate's daily newsletter.More War Stories columnsIs Libya Like Kosovo?Let's hope so. Fred Kaplan | March 23, 2011It's OnThe U.N. Security Council passed a resolution on Libya. What happens next?Fred Kaplan | March 18, 2011Don't Talk About the WarWhy didn't the Senate ask Gen. Petraeus a single hard question about Afghanistan?Fred Kaplan | March 15, 2011Search for more War Stories articlesSubscribe to the War Stories RSS feedView our complete War Stories archiveplaceAd2(commercialNode,'bigbox|2',false,'')

Inside the #Fukushima #nuclear plant. PHOTOS: http://read.bi/h82FXh #Japan

Guilty plea by soldier in Afghan civilian murder court martial: http://nyti.ms/i95t35

Chris Brown needs anger management. http://slate.me/gcGKom

placeAd2(commercialNode,'twitter',false,'') Did Women Push Obama on Libya? Black Dancer Talks Ballet, Curves, and Color Why Do Miami Police Keep Shooting Black Men? Japan Is the Land of Disaster: Photo Essay Why Nuclear Power Is Still Worth the Risk What Happens During a Nuclear Meltdown: An FP Explainer #text_links .off { display:none } featured advertiser links SPONSORED CONTENT var pl = "right_rail"; var anc = document.getElementById('bizbox_links_' + pl).getElementsByTagName("a")[0]; anc.innerHTML = bizbox_latest_title; anc.href = bizbox_latest_href; ClickTrax.init();Three Cheers for the Judge Who Smacked Down Google BooksRobert Shiller: Will the Next Dangerous Economic Bubble Be in Farmland?Is Congress Still Citing Its "Constitutional Authority" in All New Bills?The Scottish Soccer Rivalry That Has Gotten Waaay Out of HandShafer: The NYT Shouldn't Worry About the Readers Who Will Cheat Their Way Past the PaywallWill Groupon Kill the Merchants That Offer Its Great Deals?placeAd2(commercialNode,'leaderboard|2',false,'');site map | build your own Slate | the fray | about us | contact us | Slate on Facebook | search | ad choicesfeedback | help | advertise | newsletters | mobile | make Slate your homepage© Copyright 2011 Washington Post.Newsweek Interactive Co. LLCUser Agreement and Privacy Policy | All rights reserved jQuery(document).ready(function() { var jskitscript = document.createElement('script'); jskitscript.type='text/javascript'; jskitscript.src='http://cdn.js-kit.com/scripts/comments.js'; document.body.appendChild(jskitscript); }); var BF_NO_QS = true; (function( ){ BF_WIDGET_JS=document.createElement('script'); BF_WIDGET_JS.type="text/javascript"; BF_WIDGET_SRC="http://ct.buzzfeed.com/wd/UserWidget?u=slate&to=1&or=vb&wid=1&cb=" + (new Date()).getTime(); $(document).ready(function () { setTimeout(function() {document.getElementById('BF_WIDGET_1').appendChild(BF_WIDGET_JS);BF_WIDGET_JS.src=BF_WIDGET_SRC},1); }); })(); createIpadAd(); commentLoad(); checkVisitorId( 'slate.com' );selectMostTab('2');_qoptions={qacct:"p-5cYn7dCzvaeyA"}; if (typeof jQuery == 'function') { jQuery(".partner_feed_cntr img, #article_bottom_tools img, #also_in_slate_bottom img, .jsk-ItemUserAvatarWrapper img, .js-kit-like-avatar img").lazyload({ placeholder : "http://img.slate.com/images/cleardot.gif", effect : "fadeIn" }); } if (typeof jQuery == 'function') { jQuery(document).ready(function() { window._sf_endpt=(new Date()).getTime(); var e = document.createElement('script'); e.setAttribute('language', 'javascript'); e.setAttribute('type', 'text/javascript'); e.setAttribute('src', (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://s3.amazonaws.com/" : "http://") + "static.chartbeat.com/js/chartbeat.js"); document.body.appendChild(e); }); }

Guilty plea by soldier in Afghan civilian murder court martial: http://nyti.ms/i95t35

Chris Brown needs anger management. http://slate.me/gcGKom

Read Full Article »
Comment
Show commentsHide Comments

Related Articles