February 11, 2012

U.S. Can Live With an Afghan Loss

James Traub, Foreign Policy

AP Photo

"It was Leon being Leon." This is the take you get when you ask Obama administration officials exactly what it was that Defense Secretary Leon Panetta meant when he said last week that the administration wanted to move troops in Afghanistan from "a combat role to a training, advise and assist role…hopefully by mid- to the latter part of 2013." Panetta, that is, was just blurting something out, as is his wont. The administration didn't so much walk back Panetta's remark as frog-march it. CIA director David Petraeus complained in congressional testimony that Panetta's comments had been "over-analyzed." White House spokesman Jay Carney explained that the Pentagon chief was speaking of what "could happen," not what had been decided. A senior NATO official told me...

Read Full Article ››

TAGGED: United States, Afghanistan

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

February 2, 2012
Mr. President, Our Wars Are Not Over
Lawrence Kaplan, The New Republic
“In America, and in Iraq,” Vice President Joe Biden assured an audience in Baghdad last December, “the tide of war is receding.” For its callowness, this observation was noteworthy. (The tide of war was... more ››
February 6, 2012
U.S. Comes Up Short in Afghanistan
Patrick Cockburn, The Independent
The United States' announcement that it plans to end the combat role of its troops in Afghanistan earlier than expected, and before the end of next year, is a crucial milestone in the international forces' retreat from the... more ››
February 5, 2012
Obama Made the Right Call on Afghanistan
James Joyner, The Atlantic
Hastening America's exit will be painful, and undercuts years of U.S. efforts, but it's our least bad choice in this doomed war. more ››
February 4, 2012
America Rushes for the Afghan Exit
The Economist
SPEAKING on February 1st shortly before a meeting of NATO ministers in Brussels, Leon Panetta, America’s defence secretary, dropped a bombshell. He said that he now hoped American troops in Afghanistan would be able to withdraw... more ››
February 9, 2012
U.S. Can't Force Afghan Reconciliation
Peter Tomsen, Los Angeles Times
In 1989, soon after I was appointed U.S. special envoy and ambassador on Afghanistan, the late mujahedin commander Abdul Haq conveyed a warning to me. Attempts by foreigners to organize the unruly, unpredictable and divided... more ››