Clooney and Satellite Spying

Clooney and Satellite Spying

Business News l Skip to Main Content

By Daniel Tovrov: Subscribe to Daniel's RSS feed

March 16, 2012 10:38 AM EDT

George Clooney believes that he has found evidence of the Sudanese government murdering its own citizens. Using images from space satellites, the Hollywood actor, with help from the Satellite Sentinel Project (SSP), documented crimes against humanity taking place in sub-Saharan Africa.

"It is absolutely without question a war crime that we saw firsthand," the actor told the Senate Foreign Relations Committee while presenting his findings on Wednesday.

While Clooney's efforts are patently good, are they ethical? No project like this has ever been done before, and so Clooney and his partners are making the rules as they go, albeit rules within the strictures of international law.

SSP is a collaboration between the non-profit Enough Project, the Harvard Humanitarian Initiative and DigitalGlobe Inc. (NYSE: DG),  a publicly-traded space imagery company. The whole enterprise is funded by Clooney and his Not on Our Watch organization.

"This is a collaboration that in itself is revolutionary. No one could do it alone," said Nathaniel Raymond, the Director of Operations for the SSP.  Must Read Slower Growth In Medicare Spending Seen As Boomers Hit Eligibility North Korea's Planned Rocket Launch Alarms South Korea, US, Japan Sponsorship Link

Like us on Facebook

Using field reporting from the Enough Project and DigitalGlobe's satellite images, which are directed and interpreted by Harvard, SSP monitors what it sees as an ongoing humanitarian crisis in Sudan that started with the Second Civil War in 1983, bred the genocide in Darfur and essentially continued uninterrupted as it developed into the ethnic conflict surrounding South Sudan's independence.

Sudan Bombed Its Own People

SSP's findings are impressive and important, and its methodology is revolutionary in its own right. The group has satellite images that show -- more conclusively than anyone else has been able to show -- the Sudanese government using jets to bomb unarmed civilians, particularly the indigenous people in the Nuba Mountains.

"The Khartoum regime has been caught in the act of bombing their own civilians," John C. Bradshaw, Executive Director of the Enough Project, said in a statement.

"Their campaign of fear against the people of the Nuba Mountains is using tactics that could be considered war crimes."

Among other things, like alleged mass graves, SSP showed that the government of President Omar al-Bashir sent Antonov An-26 Curl military planes to bomb villages in South Kordofan, a state on the Sudan side of the border with South Sudan that has been rife with death and displacement for decades.

According to the SSP, these recent attacks were unprovoked acts of aggression and attempts at ethnic cleansing.

"Indiscriminate attacks, including bombings, of civilians violates international law," said Bradshaw. "Indiscriminate bombings terrorize vulnerable people, even when the bombings kill or wound no one. The Government of Sudan must stop all indiscriminate attacks against civilians."

Private Satellites Watch Foreign Governments

If true, Bashir's campaign is immoral and illegal. But does Clooney's project, which uses a private corporation's satellite to watch a foreign government, suffer from its own ethical problems?

"We are not in (Sudan's) airspace. We have not violated their sovereignty. We have not violated international law," SSP's Raymond said, adding that the use of unauthorized drones or spy planes would be different.

Harvard and SSP aren't simply looking at satellite photos already in a database or comparing Google Earth stills. Nor are they even taking pictures in a traditional sense, but rather interpreting data and to find things like the size and type of camouflaged tanks and the direction those tanks are moving in.

"We physically task the (DigitalGlobe) satellites. We ask 'the bird' to go over a location. Like in a movie. But it's Harvard, and not the CIA," said Raymond.

Clooney, the actor who famously said that Hollywood talked "about AIDS when it was just being whispered, and we talked about civil rights when it wasn't really popular" during his 2006 Oscar acceptance speech, also disagrees with critics who question his projects ethics.

"It's spying if it's a country. It's spying if it's the United Nations, maybe. But what if I'm a paparazzo with a lens 400 miles up? How is that spying? I'm just a tourist taking pictures and putting it on the Web. I don't understand where that's wrong," Clooney has said in response to such ethical questions.

Satellite Legacy

But governments have been using satellite surveillance for decades. It is considered spying, but the images are kept private and theoretically only used for national security purposes.

Then again, is SSP's private monitoring any ethically different than having an undercover reporter in Sudan? Raymond thinks it's actually much, much more effective.

"We hope this is a proof of concept for something that will become ubiquitous in our tool-kit. Just like forensic science was an anomaly in human rights work and is now mainstream," Raymond said.

"In this project is the DNA of a larger revolution," said Raymond.

Next, there needs to be a new "ethical code, legal basis and codified ethics for those being mapped," he added.

"With success comes responsibility."

To report problems or to leave feedback about this article, e-mail: mail("d.tovrov","ibtimes",0,"?Subject=FEEDBACK: [315304] George Clooney And The New Ethics Of Satellite Surveillance&","Mr Nobody")To contact the editor, e-mail: mail("editor","ibtimes",0,"?Subject=FEEDBACK: [315304] George Clooney And The New Ethics Of Satellite Surveillance&","Editor")

This article is copyrighted by International Business Times, the business news leader Comments Send This Aricle Share This Aricle Popular Multimedia 'Mad Men' Stars Arrive for Fifth Season Premiere 5 Ill-Fated Celebrity Marriages That Ended In Divorce Self-Appointed Batman Protects Slovakian Town 'The Hunger Games' Stars At Premiere News From US Violence Against Women Act: Protections For Immigrants Fuel Political Fight

As Senate Democrats and Republicans spar over a proposal to reauthorize the Violence Against Women Act, measures to shield immigrants from domestic violence have become a sticking point.

Slower Growth In Medicare Spending Seen As Boomers Hit Eligibility Missouri, Puerto Rico Caucuses Explained: Don't Expect Santorum Boost By Monday EPA Says No Evidence Fracking Polluted Water In Rural Pa. Editor's Pick 1 2 3 Afghanistan: Does War-Battered Country Have Energy Wealth?

As Jobs Reports Show Growth, Economists Present Divergent Visions of the Recovery's Future; Is Washington Listening?

India To Surpass Japan As No. 2 Asian Car Market By 2016

Encyclopedia Britannica Ending Print Publication

Rebekah Brooks: The Scandal That Mixes Low-Brow Culture With The Upper Crust

Climate Change, Rising Water To Endanger U.S. Cities: Study

Instagram is Coming Soon to Android

U.S., Europe Data Boost Stocks, Dollar

Apple Subpoenaed By FTC As Part Of Google Probe

Join the Conversation /* * * CONFIGURATION VARIABLES: EDIT BEFORE PASTING INTO YOUR WEBPAGE * * */ var disqus_shortname = 'ibtimes'; // required: replace example with your forum shortname var disqus_category_id=1164753; // The following are highly recommended additional parameters. Remove the slashes in front to use. var disqus_identifier = 'articles_315304'; var disqus_url = ''; /* * * DON'T EDIT BELOW THIS LINE * * */ (function() { var dsq = document.createElement('script'); dsq.type = 'text/javascript'; dsq.async = true; dsq.src = 'http://' + disqus_shortname + ''; (document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0] || document.getElementsByTagName('body')[0]).appendChild(dsq); })(); Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus. Most popular Emailed Discussed Viewed Brown Recluse Spider Bite Nearly Blinds Texas Student Nikki Perez

Perez, 21, a student at Texas Christian University in Fort Worth, was travelling with her boyfriend and his mother last September when she was bitten by a brown recluse spider.

Goldman Sachs Loses $2.15 Billion of Its Market Value Arizona Birth Control Bill Allows Employers To Fire Women On The Pill Based On Religious Beliefs NCAA Tournament 2012 Expert Predictions: How to Fill Out Your Bracket and Win Your Office Pool with Upset Picks; Plus PDF Printable Brackets [March Madness] Chicken Jerky Dog Treats Linked to Illness: 3 Important Questions Answered Moroccan Girl Commits Suicide over Forced Marriage to Rapist Japan Earthquake 2012: Tokyo At Risk For Major Disaster In Near Future 'Dark Shadows' Trailer Debuts With Movie Stills, Watch It Here [PHOTOS & VIDEO]

The trailer for Tim Burton's movie "Dark Shadows" debuted on Ellen on Thursday and the video has already made its w...

Apple Stock Closes At $552, Exceeds Exxon Market Cap By $100B JYJ in South America: K-Pop Fever Hits Chile, Peru [PHOTOS] Arizona Birth Control Bill Allows Employers To Fire Women On The Pill Based On Religious Beliefs Brown Recluse Spider Bite Nearly Blinds Texas Student Nikki Perez Goldman Sachs Loses $2.15 Billion of Its Market Value iOS 5.1 Features Review: Problems Range From Battery Drain To Weak 4G iPhone 5 Release Rumor: Has Apple Planned Something Bigger, Better and Pricier?

Apple will soon extend its flagship iPhone version with iPhone 5. Is it going to be bigger, better and pricier? Foxconn report confirms about the bigger screen size and Verizon confirms 4G LTE.

Goldman Sachs Loses $2.15 Billion of Its Market Value IPhone 5 Release Date 2012: 5 Reasons To Avoid 4G LTE Service, Especially For Verizon Wireless Samsung Galaxy S3: Top 5 Competitors of the Android Phone Japan Earthquake 2012: Tokyo At Risk For Major Disaster In Near Future iPad 3 Release Date is Here: Where to Buy, Specs, Review, Pros and Cons vs iPod 2, Share Price and More for the Tech Giant 'Diablo 3' Release Date 2012: Blizzard Announces May 15 Launch, Where To Pre-Order The Game OAS_AD('Right1'); ADVERTISE WITH US /*TV */ .bk_playtv1 .heading {border-top:1px solid #d8dce5; border-left:1px solid #d8dce5; border-right:1px solid #d8dce5; padding:5px 10px 3px 10px; height:27px;} .bk_playtv1 .heading .title { background:url("") no-repeat scroll 0 0 transparent; float: left;text-indent: -9999px;height:27px;width:85px;} .bk_playtv1 .heading .more { float: right;} .bk_playtv1 .heading .more a { background: url("") no-repeat scroll -409px -92px transparent; padding:4px 9px 0 0; font-size: 11px; font-weight:bold; color:#000000; text-transform: uppercase; display:block;} .bk_playtv1 .tv_new { padding-top:0px;} IBTimes TV More var tvplayer = $f("tvplayer",{src:"",wmode:"transparent"},{ playlist:[{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""}, {url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""},{url: ""}], canvas:{backgroundColor:"#000000",backgroundGradient:"none"}, clip:{scaling:"fit",linkUrl:"",linkWindow:"_blank"}, plugins:{ stats:{url:""}, controls:{autoHide:"always"}, ova:{ url:"", "autoPlay":true, "canFireAPICalls":true, "player": {"controls":{"height":28}}, "ads": { "playOnce":false, "pauseOnClickThrough":true, "setDurationFromMetaData":true, "notice":{"textStyle":"smalltext"}, "linearScaling":"fit", "companions": {"restore": true,"html5": true,"millisecondDelayOnInjection": 200,"regions": [{"id":"companion_300x250","width":300,"height":250}]}, "schedule": [{ "zone":"us.ibtimes/tv/articles@x60", "position":"pre-roll", "loadOnDemand":true, "refreshOnReplay":true, "server": { "type": "OAS", "apiAddress": "", "timeoutInSeconds": 20, "forceImpressionServing": true, "customProperties" : { "target": ["","_RM_HTML_ADMAP_=in%3A%3A0","_RM_HTML_DESCRIPTION_=","_RM_HTML_TITLE_=","_RM_HTML_VIDEOID_=4177", "_RM_HTML_VIEWIP_="] }, "failoverServers": [{ "type": "OAS", "tag": "" }] } },{ "position":"post-roll", "loadOnDemand":true, "refreshOnReplay":true, "zone":"us.ibtimes/tv/articles@x30", "server":{ "type": "OAS", "apiAddress": "", "timeoutInSeconds": 20, "forceImpressionServing": true, "customProperties" : {"target": [""]}, "failoverServers": [{"type": "OAS","tag": ""}] } }] }, "debug":{"levels": "fatal,config,vast_template,vpaid,tracking_events","debugger":"firebug"} } } }).ipad();

Bayern Munich thrash Hoffenheim

Most Viewed 1 2 3 Gold Beats Back a Dollar Rally to Close Above $1,700 Gold Falls Below its 200-Day Moving Average Platinum Climbs For Fifth Day Gold Reverses Three-Day Plunge Most Read George Clooney And The New Ethics Of Satellite Surveillance Bianca Jones Missing: 2-Year-Old's Father D'andre Lane Charged With Murder Adam Regis Murder Victim's Mother Posts Video Appeal to Killers [VIDEO] Most Discussed Arizona Birth Control Bill Allows Employers To Fire Women On The Pill Based On Religious BeliefsRead Full Article »
Show commentsHide Comments

Related Articles