December 11, 2012

How Good a General Was Petraeus?

Dexter Filkins, The New Yorker

AP Photo

In recent years, the most esteemed officer in America—the very model of the modern general—was David Petraeus, whose public image combined the theorizing of the new school with a patina of old-fashioned toughness and rectitude. Before a sex scandal forced him to step down as the director of the C.I.A., a few weeks ago, he was widely regarded by politicians and journalists as a brilliant thinker and leader, the man who saved America in Iraq and might work a similar miracle in Afghanistan. Roger Ailes suggested, perhaps less than half in jest, that Petraeus run for President. Now many of the same people are calling into question not just his ethics but his basic ideas and achievements. History often forgives military leaders for small scandals, if they are successful enough....

Read Full Article ››

TAGGED: Counter-Insurgency, Afghanistan, Iraq, David Petraeus

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

December 7, 2012
All Quiet in Helmand Province
Matthieu Aikins, Latitude
I’d always counted myself as skeptical of the so-called surge, the 33,000 extra U.S. troops that President Barack Obama sent to Afghanistan between 2008 and 2011. Afghanistan’s fundamental problems aren’t amenable to... more ››
December 7, 2012
Prepare an Afghanistan Contingency Force
MacDonald & Kamminga, FP
With all combat troops scheduled to be withdrawn from Afghanistan by the end of 2014, the negotiations taking place in Kabul on the presence and role of U.S. troops in Afghanistan beyond that point must include a plan for a... more ››
December 2, 2012
Redrawing the Mideast Map
Thomas Friedman, New York Times
Syria is the keystone of the Middle East. If and how it cracks apart could recast this entire region. The borders of Syria have been fixed ever since the British and French colonial powers carved up the Arab provinces of the... more ››
December 7, 2012
Arab-Kurd War Looms in Iraq
Ranj Alaaldin, The National
Yet another Arab-Kurd civil war is unlikely to materialise, but expect brinkmanship by Baghdad ahead of provincial elections in 2013. Mr Al Maliki has asserted himself in the same way before, such as in the 2008 Kurd-Arab... more ››