January 9, 2013

Leaving Afghanistan: A Lesson from USSR

Daveed Gartenstein, The Atlantic

AP Photo

One unique feature of Afghanistan's history, in addition to the ubiquity of foreign invasions that stretch back for 2600 years, is the manner in which one would-be conqueror after another found its position compromised due to its failure to understand this history. "The British would repeat the blunders of the Romans," writes Peter Tomsen in The Wars of Afghanistan, arguing that their nineteenth century invasions overlooked lessons that could be gleaned from the defeat the Romans suffered at the Battle of Carrhae in 53 B.C. And, he added, "the Soviets would make the same mistakes a century...

Read Full Article ››

TAGGED: Soviet Union, United States, Afghanistan

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

January 15, 2013
Obama's Afghan Mission Shrink
Washington Post
To preserve a stable Afghanistan after 2014, the United States and its allies would have to leave behind sufficient forces to enable the Afghan army — which currently boasts only one brigade able to act independently — to... more ››
January 15, 2013
America Steps Back as Global Policeman
George Friedman, Stratfor
Accepting an ongoing threat is also difficult. Mitigating the threat of an enemy rather than defeating the enemy outright goes against an impulse. But it is not something alien to American strategy. The United States is involved... more ››
January 14, 2013
Obama's Sort-of War on Terror
Victor Davis Hanson, National Review
Foreign policy often proves ironic. Sometimes chaos and confusion have their place. By posing as a post-national Nobel laureate, by promulgating all sorts of politically correct bromides, and by serially trashing the unpopular... more ››
January 14, 2013
Sour U.S.-Russia Ties Threaten Obama Abroad
Anne Gearan, Wash Post
A poisonous unraveling of U.S. relations with Russia in recent months represents more than the failure of President Obama's first-term attempt to "reset" badly frayed bilateral relations. It threatens pillars of Obama’s... more ››
January 16, 2013
Why America Lost in Afghanistan
Steven Metz, World Politics Review
Last week's meeting between U.S. President Barack Obama and Afghan President Hamid Karzai felt like a last desperate attempt to salvage a crumbling marriage: With the relationship clearly dying, the two sides quibbled over the... more ››