January 13, 2013

Iran and the Fallacy of Saber-Rattling

Paul Pillar, The National Interest

AP Photo

Among several broadly held misconceptions about Iran is that to get Iranians to make concessions we want them to make at the negotiating table the United States must credibly threaten to inflict dire harm on them—specifically, with military force—if they do not make the concessions. Some in the United States (and some in Israel) who are especially keen on promoting this notion would welcome a war. If war preparations and brinksmanship used to communicate such a threat lead the two nations to stumble into an accidental war—and there is a real danger they might—so much the better from their point of view. But the belief in saber-rattling as an aid to gaining an agreement in the negotiations over Iran's nuclear program extends to many who actually want an agreement...

Read Full Article ››

TAGGED: Iran

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

January 14, 2013
Message to Iran: This Obama Team Is Ready to Deal
Hussein Ibish, NOW
Obama's new defense/foreign policy team is an Iran cabinet, assembled to decide and act on war or peace over the nuclear file. Tehran should understand this as both the unparalleled opportunity and significant threat that it is.... more ››
January 14, 2013
Getting to "Yes" with Iran
Robert Jervis, Foreign Affairs
It might be wise for the United States to resign itself to Iran's development of nuclear weapons and to focus on deterring the Islamic Republic from ever using them. But U.S. leaders have explicitly rejected that course of... more ››
January 14, 2013
Following the Tehran Terror Trail
New York Daily News
The temperature is spiking in the warm war between the U.S. and Iran. President Obama's national security team, which has a history of trying to engage the mullahtocracy, must recognize the limits of talk. more ››
January 14, 2013
Sour U.S.-Russia Ties Threaten Obama Abroad
Anne Gearan, Wash Post
A poisonous unraveling of U.S. relations with Russia in recent months represents more than the failure of President Obama's first-term attempt to "reset" badly frayed bilateral relations. It threatens pillars of Obama’s... more ››
January 13, 2013
Trail of Bullets Links Iran to African Wars
C.J. Chivers, New York Times
The trail of evidence uncovered by the investigation included Iranian cartridges in the possession of rebels in Ivory Coast, federal troops in the Democratic Republic of Congo, the Taliban in Afghanistan and groups affiliated... more ››