Even as Iraq's ruptured Sunni-Shi'ite divide appears to be tenuously mending, another seam in the country's patchwork multi-ethnic and sectarian society is on the verge of unraveling. Territorial disputes between Arabs and Kurds — in the provinces of Nineveh, Kirkuk and Diyala — now pose a serious risk of violence.
In recent months, longstanding hostility between the two communities has escalated, whipped up by resurgent Arab secular nationalism. At the federal level, Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki has repeatedly said he wants to strengthen Baghdad's hand at the expense of Iraq's 18 provinces, including Kurdistan — the semi-autonomous three-province Kurdish region in the north — much to the chagrin of the federalist-minded Kurds. At the provincial level, newly empowered hard-line Sunni groups like Al-Hadba in Mosul, Nineveh's capital, are readying to expand their political clout. (See a photographer's diary of the Iraq conflict.)
Al-Hadba won 19 of the provincial council's 37 seats during elections in January, running on an anti-Kurdish platform in the volatile, still-violent, mixed but predominantly Sunni province. Its victory was a realignment of power away from the minority Kurds who held disproportionate sway due to a Sunni electoral boycott in 2005. However, it has also set the stage for a showdown between the two groups. (Read an analysis of Iraq's future.)
At stake is the control of disputed territories. Kurds say they are reclaiming areas like the oil-rich city of Kirkuk that was theirs until Saddam Hussein forcibly removed them from it. Arabs say the land wasn't Kurdish to begin with. In the meantime, Kurdish Peshmerga militia forces, which operate independently of Baghdad and are answerable to Kurdistan's regional government, have steadily pushed south of their United Nations-delineated border into contested zones.
In Nineveh, Al-Hadba has vowed to push them back. "We reject the presence of the Peshmerga," says Atheel Nujaifi, the party's leader and the presumptive governor of Nineveh. "We want the only force in Nineveh province to be a legitimate, government force that follows the command of the Iraqi security forces." Top U.S military commanders in Nineveh say Nujaifi's stance is just electoral bluster. But he insists he is being serious. Nujaifi says that as soon as he is sworn in and the new government seated, he will request that Baghdad formally ask the Kurdish regional government in Erbil to withdraw its Peshmerga from Nineveh.
"These forces can't be pulled out just because Atheel Nujaifi says so in the media," says Fryad Rwandzi, a Kurdish member of parliament and spokesman for the 58-strong Kurdish bloc in the national parliament. "We, as Kurds, have the authority to defend our people; 172,000 Kurdish people were driven away from Mosul [during Saddam's Arabization period]. These forces [tje Peshmerga] are to protect the Kurdish people." (See a story about the prosperous state of Iraqi Kurdistan.)
It can all go very wrong very quickly. Last summer, Iraqi security forces and Peshmerga almost came to blows in the disputed area of Khanaqin, in Diyala province, after Iraqi troops tried to enter the mixed town. There are dozens of similarly contested zones in Nineveh. "It would be an ugly fight," says Colonel Brian Vines, the U.S army liaison to the Nineveh Operations Command, which oversees the province's local and national police, as well as army units. "I think that in some places they're going to have to forcibly move them [Kurds] out of these disputed zones."
There are risks other than an all-out confrontation. The fledgling Iraqi security forces could fracture along ethnic or sectarian lines. A Kurdish battalion commander and 200 of his Kurdish soldiers stationed in Nineveh deserted en masse last summer during the Khanaqin standoff, taking their weapons with them into Erbil, says Colonel Vines. At the same time, a Kurdish brigade stationed in Diyala also refused orders from the central government, according to other sources.
Kurds say that Maliki has allegedly been quietly rotating senior Kurdish officers out of army units stationed in volatile provinces including Nineveh and replacing them with Arabs. That's disputed by Maj. Gen. Hassan Kareem Abbas, the Shi'ite commander of the Nineveh Operations Command. Kurdish officers have been replaced, the general says, but by other Kurds, a view supported privately by senior U.S officers in Mosul.
The U.S is increasingly caught in the middle even as it continues its military mission against die-hard insurgents in places like Mosul, mindful of the fast-approaching deadline to withdraw American forces from Iraqi cities by the end of June, ahead of a complete pullout by 2011. "I don't know if I'm a mediator," says Col. Gary Volesky, brigade commander of the 3rd Heavy Combat Team, 1st Cavalry Division stationed in Mosul, adding that his mission was to rout out insurgents. Still, Kurdish leaders, including Nechirvan Barzani, Prime Minister of Iraqi Kurdistan, have said they want the U.S to stay not only in the cities, but in Iraq, until it helps resolve outstanding Kurdish-Arab issues including disputed territories. That's unlikely, unless the land rivalry can be resolved in the next two years.
What is clear is that there's a new order in Iraq, an invigorated Arab nationalism that is increasingly pushing back against federalist-minded groups like the country's Kurds. Will the Kurds concede that they may not be in a position to get everything that they want, especially regarding territory? Or will they respond militarily? "It's not a simple issue," says Rwandzi, the Kurdish member of parliament, "it's very sensitive and needs to be dealt with seriously." That much at least, Iraq's Arabs and Kurds can agree on.
See a month-by-month catalog of America's six years in Iraq.
In Mosul, Iraq's Insurgency Refuses to be Tamed.
Connect to this TIME Story Interact with this story time:http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1887189,00.html?iid=ybuzz_share function fbs_click() {u=location.href;t=document.title;window.open('http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u='+encodeURIComponent(u)+'&t='+encodeURIComponent(t),'sharer','toolbar=0,status=0,width=626,height=436');return false;} html .fb_share_link { padding:2px 0 0 20px; height:16px; background:url(http://static.ak.fbcdn.net/images/share/facebook_share_icon.gif?0:26981) no-repeat top left; }Facebook digg_url = 'http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1887189,00.html?iid=digg_share'; digg_title = 'Arab-Kurd Tensions Could Threaten Iraq's Peace'; digg_bodytext = 'Territorial disputes between the Kurds and the rest of the country — both Sunni and Shi'ite — may bring political and military turmoil back to Iraq'; digg_bgcolor = '#fff'; digg_skin = 'compact'; digg_window = 'new'; digg_thumbnails = '1'; Email Sphere.Inline.search("sphereFooter","http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1887189,00.html") tiiQuigoWriteAd(755777, 1391548, 525, 240, -1); adFactory.getCmAd(525, 35, "article", "tout").write(); adFactory.getCmAd(300, 15, "global", "tout").write(); Top Stories on Time.com Celebrity Twittering: Is That Really You, Shaq? Tax Time in a Tough Economy: 10 Recession Tips Arab-Kurd Tensions Could Threaten Iraq's Peace China's Proposal on the Dollar: Good for the U.S. Solar Power: Eco-Friendly or Environmental Blight? adFactory.getMultiAd(new Array("336x280", "336x850", "300x250", "300x600")).write(); Most Popular » Full List » Most Read The World's Cheapest Car Debuts in IndiaDespite DNA Evidence, Twins Charged in Heist Go FreeIs Drywall the Next Chinese Import Scandal? Why S--- HappensA Quiet Revolution Grows in the Muslim WorldObama's Overture to Iran: Why Khamenei Won't BudgeThe Next DimensionWhy It's Getting Harder to Evade Taxes The 10 Most Endangered Newspapers in AmericaSenator Gregg and the Princes Of Anarchy Most Emailed Is Dry Wall the Next Chinese Import Scandal? Scholar Claims Dead Sea Scrolls 'Authors' Never Existed The World's Cheapest Car Debuts in India How to Bring An End to the War Over Sex Ed The 10 Most Endangered Newspapers in America A Gay-Marriage Solution: End Marriage? A Quiet Revolution Grows in the Muslim World 3. The New Calvinism - 10 Ideas Changing the World Right Now - TIME What Happens When a Town Loses Its Newspaper? Despite DNA Evidence, Twins Charged in Heist Go Free var ad = adFactory.getAd(88, 31); ad.setPosition(9); ad.write(); /time/includes/homepage_video.xml Video More Videos » Today in Pictures » Browse All Photos » tiiQuigoWriteAd(755777, 1402931, 300, 170, -1); Quotes of the Day » Get & Share $Launchpad.CreateMenu({ wid : "491cae4a5db36d0d", actionElement : "myWidget"}); "I already miss the little children's voices squealing and having a good time." LOLA BENSON, a neighbor of the Jacobson family in St. Helena, Calif., which lost all five members in Sunday's plane crash in Montana More Quotes » var ad = adFactory.getAd(88, 31); ad.setPosition(12) ad.write(); adFactory.getCmAd(300, 250, "global", "tout").write(); adFactory.getCmAd(300, 100, "article", "tout").write(); CNN Headlines Peace summit scrapped after Dalai Lama row Obama calls for global economic cooperation Local aid group worker killed in Darfur var ad = adFactory.getAd(142, 70); ad.setPosition(1) ad.write(); var ad = adFactory.getAd(142, 70); ad.setPosition(2) ad.write(); var ad = adFactory.getAd(142, 70); ad.setPosition(3) ad.write(); var ad = adFactory.getAd(142, 70); ad.setPosition(4) ad.write(); World Add Time News My Yahoo! My Google Netvibes My AOL RSS Feed See all feeds var ad = adFactory.getAd(88, 31); ad.setPosition(11) ad.write(); SEARCH TIME.COM Full Archive Covers INSIDE: Main | The China Blog | The Middle East Blog | Postcards | Global Adviser | Videos | Podcast InsideTime.com Photos: American Muscle Cars in the Movies Another Reason to Visit Switzerland: Hiking in the Nude Remembering the Lessons of the Exxon Valdez The Growing Case Against Red Meat © 2009 Time Inc. All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | RSS | Newsletter | TIME For Kids Subscribe | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Media Kit | Reprints & Permissions | Opinion Leaders Panel | Help | Site Map TiiAdTrackRevSci(); _qacct='p-5dyPa639IrgIw'; quantserve(); // Initialization var _loomia_scripts_loaded=0; if (typeof L_VARS=='undefined') { L_VARS = new Object() } // Loomia common settings L_VARS.publisher_key = 9065184586; L_VARS.anchor="recommendations_display"; L_VARS.guid ="1887189"; L_VARS.query_params = {"xid" : "Loomia"}; function _loomia_addScript(url) { var anchor=document.getElementsByTagName('HEAD')[0]; var script= document.createElement("SCRIPT"); script.src=url; anchor.appendChild(script); } function _loomia_addCS() { try {_loomia_rec_type = document.getElementById(L_VARS.anchor).className; } catch(e) { _loomia_rec_type='' } if (!_loomia_scripts_loaded) {_loomia_addScript("http://assets.loomia.com/js/clixdom.js"); if (_loomia_rec_type.indexOf('similarrecs') != -1) _loomia_addScript("http://assets.loomia.com/js/simitems.js"); } _loomia_scripts_loaded=1; } // Loads Loomia script after page has loaded if (window.addEventListener) { window.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded", _loomia_addCS, false); window.addEventListener("load", _loomia_addCS, false); } else if (window.attachEvent) window.attachEvent("onload", _loomia_addCS); L_VARS.number = 3;
Al-Hadba won 19 of the provincial council's 37 seats during elections in January, running on an anti-Kurdish platform in the volatile, still-violent, mixed but predominantly Sunni province. Its victory was a realignment of power away from the minority Kurds who held disproportionate sway due to a Sunni electoral boycott in 2005. However, it has also set the stage for a showdown between the two groups. (Read an analysis of Iraq's future.)
At stake is the control of disputed territories. Kurds say they are reclaiming areas like the oil-rich city of Kirkuk that was theirs until Saddam Hussein forcibly removed them from it. Arabs say the land wasn't Kurdish to begin with. In the meantime, Kurdish Peshmerga militia forces, which operate independently of Baghdad and are answerable to Kurdistan's regional government, have steadily pushed south of their United Nations-delineated border into contested zones.
In Nineveh, Al-Hadba has vowed to push them back. "We reject the presence of the Peshmerga," says Atheel Nujaifi, the party's leader and the presumptive governor of Nineveh. "We want the only force in Nineveh province to be a legitimate, government force that follows the command of the Iraqi security forces." Top U.S military commanders in Nineveh say Nujaifi's stance is just electoral bluster. But he insists he is being serious. Nujaifi says that as soon as he is sworn in and the new government seated, he will request that Baghdad formally ask the Kurdish regional government in Erbil to withdraw its Peshmerga from Nineveh.
"These forces can't be pulled out just because Atheel Nujaifi says so in the media," says Fryad Rwandzi, a Kurdish member of parliament and spokesman for the 58-strong Kurdish bloc in the national parliament. "We, as Kurds, have the authority to defend our people; 172,000 Kurdish people were driven away from Mosul [during Saddam's Arabization period]. These forces [tje Peshmerga] are to protect the Kurdish people." (See a story about the prosperous state of Iraqi Kurdistan.)
It can all go very wrong very quickly. Last summer, Iraqi security forces and Peshmerga almost came to blows in the disputed area of Khanaqin, in Diyala province, after Iraqi troops tried to enter the mixed town. There are dozens of similarly contested zones in Nineveh. "It would be an ugly fight," says Colonel Brian Vines, the U.S army liaison to the Nineveh Operations Command, which oversees the province's local and national police, as well as army units. "I think that in some places they're going to have to forcibly move them [Kurds] out of these disputed zones."
There are risks other than an all-out confrontation. The fledgling Iraqi security forces could fracture along ethnic or sectarian lines. A Kurdish battalion commander and 200 of his Kurdish soldiers stationed in Nineveh deserted en masse last summer during the Khanaqin standoff, taking their weapons with them into Erbil, says Colonel Vines. At the same time, a Kurdish brigade stationed in Diyala also refused orders from the central government, according to other sources.
Kurds say that Maliki has allegedly been quietly rotating senior Kurdish officers out of army units stationed in volatile provinces including Nineveh and replacing them with Arabs. That's disputed by Maj. Gen. Hassan Kareem Abbas, the Shi'ite commander of the Nineveh Operations Command. Kurdish officers have been replaced, the general says, but by other Kurds, a view supported privately by senior U.S officers in Mosul.
The U.S is increasingly caught in the middle even as it continues its military mission against die-hard insurgents in places like Mosul, mindful of the fast-approaching deadline to withdraw American forces from Iraqi cities by the end of June, ahead of a complete pullout by 2011. "I don't know if I'm a mediator," says Col. Gary Volesky, brigade commander of the 3rd Heavy Combat Team, 1st Cavalry Division stationed in Mosul, adding that his mission was to rout out insurgents. Still, Kurdish leaders, including Nechirvan Barzani, Prime Minister of Iraqi Kurdistan, have said they want the U.S to stay not only in the cities, but in Iraq, until it helps resolve outstanding Kurdish-Arab issues including disputed territories. That's unlikely, unless the land rivalry can be resolved in the next two years.
What is clear is that there's a new order in Iraq, an invigorated Arab nationalism that is increasingly pushing back against federalist-minded groups like the country's Kurds. Will the Kurds concede that they may not be in a position to get everything that they want, especially regarding territory? Or will they respond militarily? "It's not a simple issue," says Rwandzi, the Kurdish member of parliament, "it's very sensitive and needs to be dealt with seriously." That much at least, Iraq's Arabs and Kurds can agree on.
See a month-by-month catalog of America's six years in Iraq.
In Mosul, Iraq's Insurgency Refuses to be Tamed.
Read Full Article »