New Labour was a brilliant idea in its time, but its time seems to have run out. In 1992 the Labour Party, led by Neil Kinnock, unexpectedly managed to lose the general election. Most Conservatives were surprised, though the 1992 victory turned out to be a poisoned chalice for their party. In 1997, under the leadership of Tony Blair and rebranded as “new Labour”, there was a 10 per cent swing to Labour; they won 418 out of 659 seats. The Conservatives won only 165.
The Labour Party manifesto for the 1997 general election put great emphasis on the “new Labour” idea, which had a strong appeal to the voters. The first sentence of the manifesto stated boldly that: “Britain will be better with New Labour”. The 1997 manifesto went on to claim that: “In each area of policy a new and distinctive approach has been mapped out, one that differs from the old left and the Conservative right. That is why Labour is new.”
Even Conservative supporters were impressed by this new Labour vision, though some of its claims seemed to be grandiose pie in the sky. “New Labour”, the manifesto stated, “is the practical arm of none other than the British people as a whole.” I do not know what that was supposed to mean. The pragmatic nature of new Labour was particularly emphasised and supported by Tony Blair himself. Old Labour was repudiated as bitter and ideological.
In 1997, in a commitment that was repeated in subsequent manifestos for the elections of 2001 and 2005, the Labour Party promised that: “There will be no return to the penal tax rates that existed under Labour and Conservative governments in the 1970s. To encourage work and reward effort, we are pledged not to raise the basic or top rates of income tax throughout the next Parliament.”
I doubt whether this was a wise pledge to make; I prefer David Cameron's resistance to tax pledges of all kinds. Tax decisions ought, in my view, to be made in the light of the economic situation at the time of the Budget. No business would fix its prices five years ahead. Nevertheless, the new Labour tax pledge was an important symbolic commitment.
By 1997, the old Labour Party had become unelectable. Tony Blair wanted to convince voters that new Labour would be different. There was no stronger symbol of new Labour's policies than the pledge not to raise the top rate of income tax. It is probable that Tony Blair wanted to tie his own party's hands.
He too must have feared that Labour's instinct to tax the rich was ingrained. Even in 2005, his third election victory, Mr Blair insisted on repeating the pledge that top rates of tax would not rise.
Such symbolic commitments have an even greater symbolic impact when they come to be broken, as Alistair Darling broke the new Labour tax pledge in his Budget last week. I am sure that this was bad economics. Britain is going to have to attract a great deal of money, if we are to meet the borrowing commitment that Mr Darling outlined in his Budget.
If you have to borrow £175 billion, you cannot afford to spit in the faces of those who have millions to lend. Because he has broken a symbolic commitment, the Chancellor has undermined his own credit and that of Britain. This could even cost Britain our triple-A credit rating.
The increase in the top rate of income tax to 50 per cent will not solve any of our financial problems. When Nigel Lawson cut the top rate to 40 per cent in 1988, the yield actually went up. It may well go down now that it has been raised.
One has to remember that it will be the most wealthy who have the strongest reason to leave the country, possibly taking all their tax with them. Those who have incomes of £160,000 or £200,000 may well stay and pay the extra tax. Those who have incomes of more than £1 million will have a strong incentive to avoid the tax or leave the country. The extra tax will not only affect the position of those who are already very rich, but also of those who think they might pass beyond the £150,000 threshold in the future.
This will therefore be a high-cost, low-yield tax, bound to damage Britain's competitive position as a business centre and as a recipient of borrowed funds. We shall lose many of our largest individual taxpayers, including senior executives in international businesses; we shall lose more of the international corporations who have to attract highly paid talent. As an economic decision, the 50 per cent band is stupid. As borrowers we cannot afford the risk to our credit position.
Yet it is surely even worse as a political decision. From 1951 to 1997 there was increasingly convincing evidence that old Labour was indeed becoming unelectable. Harold Wilson managed to win the two elections of 1974 against a weakened Ted Heath, but the Conservatives were in office for 35 out of the 46 years from 1951. That was why Tony Blair was able to convert old Labour into new Labour, despite the party's addiction to class prejudice and tax-and-spend policies.
It now seems that Tony Blair was himself the New Labour Party. Without him, it has almost ceased to exist. Gordon Brown was throughout a most unreliable supporter of the project, though he shares some of new Labour's underlying ideas.
To the voters, new Labour meant Labour without socialism, pragmatic rather than ideological, a moderate party devoted to practical welfare reforms. Tony Blair certainly believed in such a non-ideological party and made the idea of new Labour credible.
New Labour is not credible after this Budget. Gordon Brown has not been able to detach himself from the tribal prejudices of his party. He lacks the personal appeal that Tony Blair always retained for the English middle class. Labour looks uncomfortably close to the semi-socialist trade union party that can be remembered from the 20th century. Alistair Darling's Budget may be the end of the new Labour idea.
Error: Incorrect captcha
Error: "+errorString+"
Socialism has delivered much that is good in our society, capitalism delivered the funding. Brown may lose this link, believing he can fund all with no attention to wealth creation (just borrow, print etc). Thus went Russia and half the world. The British can choose now, election time is here.
peter, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia
Amen to that!
Edwin, Bucharest,
Please note the maximum number of characters is 300.
* Name
* Town
Country
* Required
Remember me
Terms and conditions PrintEmailPost to del.icio.usPost to FarkPost to Yahoo!Post to Digg Also in William Rees-Mogg The Labour smear machine has backfiredAlso in Columnists Jenny Hjul: Save £500m? Surely we can do better than thatLiam Fay: E-voting silence reveals a power problemGillian Bowditch: Susan Boyle is our age before beauty queen Times Recommends America's friendliness terrifies Tehran Sarah Palin's PR disaster A bit of police violence worth watching
OUR COLUMNISTS
Columnists
SelectDavid AaronovitchAnjana Ahuja Chris AyresJoan BakewellSimon BarnesCherie BlairCamilla CavendishJeremy ClarksonRobert CramptonDaniel FinkelsteinMichael GoveSimon JenkinsRachel JohnsonAnatole KaletskyIndia KnightDominic LawsonRod LiddleMagnus LinklaterBen MacIntyreBronwen MaddoxMinette MarrinCarol MidgleyAlice MilesCaitlin MoranRichard MorrisonMatthew ParrisMichael PortilloLibby PurvesWilliam Rees-MoggMelanie ReidPeter RiddellHugo RifkindSathnam SangheraGraham StewartAndrew SullivanRachel SylvesterJanice TurnerGuest contributors
Blogs
SelectAlpha MummyArchive BlogDavid AaronovitchAsia ExileBaby BaristaBlockbuster Buzz Gerard BakerCharles BremnerBig BrotherMary BeardComment CentralConsumer CentralCricket BlogEco WorrierFaith CentralFashionFormula OneRuth GledhillInside IraqAriel LeveIndia KnightMoneyRafael NadalNews BlogWilliam Rees-MoggRugbySinofileMick SmithSports CommentaryIrwin StelzerPeter Stothard Surf NationTechnologyTravelUrban dirtVideoWimbledon
William Rees-Mogg
William Rees-Mogg has had a distinguished career with The Times and The Sunday Times. He was Deputy Editor of The Sunday Times before becoming Editor of The Times in 1967, a position he held until 1981. He was made a life peer in 1988. Since 1992 he has been a columnist for The Times, writing on a variety of issues. He has also been chairman of the Broadcast Standards Council and British Arts Council
Read more from William Rees-Mogg Camilla Cavendish wins award for family justice campaign
Columns urging greater openness in family courts win Paul Foot Award
Cartoon More cartoons Peter Stothard
The Editor of the TLS writes on books, people and politics
A Don's Life
Mary Beard of Cambridge and the TLS on culture ancient and modern
The secret swear words in Hey Jude
But which Beatle was it?
Comment Central Award-winning Iraq coverage from Deborah Haynes
A series on the plight of Iraqi interpreters took the Tony Bevins Prize for investigative journalism
MOST READMOST COMMENTEDMOST CURIOUS Most ReadSkip Most ReadTodayAmericans told to wear masks as swine flu...How one ordinary woman solved a murderSunday Times Rich List: Bonfire of the...Q&A: Should we be worried about swine...MOST COMMENTEDSkip Editor's PickTodayWe’re fleeing high-tax Britain, say...‘Stop the Taliban now – or we...Americans told to wear masks as swine flu...British spy loses secrets in a handbagMOST CURIOUSSkip Most CuriousToday Viagra faces minuscule rival Hospital used wrong sperm to fertilise eggs Bob the Builder’s close shave with the... Superfast secret of northern lights revealed Focus Zone Northern Lights:
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Business Solutions:
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Need to Know:
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Business Wisdom:
Discover the collective power of smart thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a £500 Selfridges voucher
Social Entrepreneurs:
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Business Travel:
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
More reports:
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Northern LightsBusiness SolutionsNeed to KnowBusiness WisdomSocial EntrepreneursBusiness TravelMore reports Births, deaths, marriages
Place your announcement
Find a Lawyer
Cut your legal costs
Free CV Review
Sell yourself! Have your CV reviewed by experts
Crossword Club
Sign up today or try one of our free demo crosswords
Announcements
Search The Times Births, Marriages & Deaths
Online Sudoku with daily prizes Popular Searches on Times Online bollywood news | britain's got talent | chess | dating | fashion | mortgages | movie trailers | music | podcasts | recipes | redundancy | savings | slumdog millionaire | sudoku | twilight | university guide | watchmen | wine
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
Classifieds CarsJobsPropertyTravel CarsSkip Cars of the WeekAudi A5 Diesel Coupe 30 Tdi Quattro Sport 2dr Tip Auto
2009 46,276
Maserati Granturismo Coupe V8 S 2dr Auto Q7 3.0 TDi QUATTRO S line Automatic
2008 79500
Mercedes-Benz SL 63 AMG
2009 84,995
Car insurance
Great car insurance deals online
Search for more cars and bikes JobsSkip Jobs of the WeekCommercial Director
£150 k Mark Spiers and Associates UK
Progressive Management Oppoutunities
Attractive salary Waitrose London,South East & Southern England
Area Manager (Wales)
£63,000 + benefits Environment Agency Wales
Chief Executive Officer
£80,000+Bonus YMCA East London
Search more Jobs PropertiesLooking to Buy? Looking to Sell? Kinleigh Folkard & Hayward
Completely London
Rushmore Condo's
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
South Africa - Cape Town
World Cup Investment Opp - 2 bed gated apartment
Octagon
Aspirational Homes from an Inspirational Company
Search for more properties
Read Full Article »