Tigers Beaten, But It's Not Over Yet

Michael Clarke, The Times May 19, 2009

The Sri Lankan Army is celebrating victory as its elite forces occupy the Tamil Tigers' last refuge at the Mulathive Lagoon, thanks to Chinese military aid. Since 2007 China has equipped the Sri Lankan Government with all the weapons and support the rest of the world had denied it, in return for permission to build a strategic port at Hambantota in the south.

For the Sri Lankan Government, this bloody victory means facing down international outrage at the civilian suffering it has caused. More than 100,000 people have died in this war, at least 30,000 in the past two years alone. But Sri Lanka's Government will live with that. It calculates that history will recognise a stunning military victory, after 26 years, against an insurgent force that had been a model of ruthless determination.

The Tamil Tigers were unique in blending fear and terror with a successful campaign in the world's media; not to mention running their own significant navy and a small air force that was unstoppable, until the Chinese gave Colombo half a dozen F7 fighters. For the Sri Lankan Government, the end of an insurgency that once controlled almost a third of its territory on behalf of the Tamil fifth of the population is an end that justifies the means.

This cynical calculation, however, is based on a number of assumptions that the Sri Lankan Government is only guessing at. It portrays the Tigers as alienated from the Tamil population. This is not necessarily untrue - the Tigers were cruel - but the Sinhalese chauvinism of the majority gave the Tamils plenty to resent. And this sort of ruthless military victory always creates stories of atrocities - the raw material for breeding new fighters. It is not clear that the Government of Mahinda Rajapaksa has the will or skill to break the cycle of fear and hatred that is passed down the generations.

The Government also assumes that the military campaign is over. But there are no convincing examples of serious insurgencies ever being eradicated by military force alone. Around half the insurgencies since 1945 have ended with the insurgent groups achieving some greater measure of autonomy. Less than a quarter of insurgencies end up in successful secession or governmental takeover.

Most insurgencies make some political impact, but then get trapped within their own liberation myths, criminality and incipient violence to become like a grumbling appendix in the body politic; until they burst or else history catches up with them to create a new political situation.

The nearest example to the Sri Lankan victory would be the Russia campaigns in Chechnya. A second, decade-long war has ground to a halt, leaving Chechnya devastated, cowed and resentful under the control of an unstable puppet president. Moscow claims the war is over, but violence continues; that the violence isn't more intense is more to do with exhaustion than acceptance of the Moscow-dominated status quo.

Successful counter-insurgency campaigns are fundamentally political rather than military. Force has an indispensable role to play if a terrorist or guerrilla group is making territory ungovernable. But military force is a necessary and not a sufficient condition for victory. As David Petraeus, the successful US commander in Iraq, is fond of saying: the target of American actions is the insurgency, not the individual insurgent. So the military must be subordinate to a political authority that aims to make the insurgents irrelevant in the eyes of those people who might otherwise support them. The legitimacy and effectiveness of the government has to displace the appeal or the fear of the insurgents.

This was successfully achieved by the British against a communist insurgency in Malaya. But 10,000 insurgents required more than 40,000 Commonwealth troops, a quarter of a million local police and 12 years of painful campaigning to bring an essentially political end to that emergency in 1960. Even then, another smaller insurgency flared up seven years later and lasted until 1989.

In Northern Ireland the military had a poor start and the IRA set the pace. But by the late 1970s the soldiers had learnt painful lessons and were operationally on top of the IRA. There was no more that they could do; the 1980s were a period of stalemate, waiting for a political settlement to take shape - which exhaustion and generational change gradually achieved after the ceasefires of 1994. Fifteen years later those ceasefires still cannot be taken for granted.

Mr Rajapaksa's Government should not be so confident that it has won. After a shaky peace broke down in 2005 it committed itself, partly out of exasperation, to outright offensives against the Tamil Tigers. It gave up entirely on the “hearts and minds” aspects of the problem. So the Tamil Tigers may be beaten in the audacious military guise they adopted but Tamil nationalism is not dead, even if it is stunned by the defeat. It will not be surprising if it finds new, and probably violent, ways of expressing itself again within the next couple of years.

Professor Michael Clarke is director of the Royal United Services Institute

Great article. One parameter not considered was that Sri Lanka had basically a toy parade army of just a few thousand men in 1983 when the insurgency started. For much of the war approx 30,000 Tamil rebels faced 50,000 SL troops. Only in the last phase did the army grow to its current size

Sid, Singapore, Singapore

A long and bitter lesson learned by the forces will ensure that any future armed struggles will be violently dealt with. It is not an ethnic thing as there was a Sinhala Marxist youth uprising where a similar number of people died, innocents included. The SL govt will now give the forces more power

Saman Kumara, Trincomalee, Sri Lanka

A by product of the war is the creation of a fearless fighting force that will lead in UN peacekeeping roles. So it is very unlikely that any violent uprising will get traction in the future, and a permanent army of 200K strong is the result of this lesson. Economic growth will reduce this cost.

Saman Kumara, Trincomalee, Sri Lanka

Excellent article. What I have witnessed is that moderate Tamils, who previously were anti LTTE, are now more than ever in favour of the resolutions that LTTE tried to achieve. They are also more than ever willing to make greater financial and personal sacrifices.

Rohan, Hong Kong, Hong Kong

rightly said.

kokila, singapore, singapore

Damn right! Reformation Reformation Reformation! Until Tamils get back their homeland, Until Tamils get recognition.........

Hannah, London,

Please note the maximum number of characters is 300.

* Name

* Email

* Town

Country

* Required

Remember me

Terms and conditions Print Email Post to del.icio.us Post to Fark Post to Yahoo! Post to Digg Also in Guest contributors Every soldier is subject to British law It's a crying shame as Cannes does Disney The Tigers are beaten but it isn't over yet Also in Columnists Europe waits for Germany to come to the rescue Fiona McCade: Do you come to the water cooler often? That’s no pistol in your pocket, my little darling Times Recommends Where are the images of horror from Sri Lanka? From Mona Lott to Katie Price Television villains: crocodile tears, lies and videotape

OUR COLUMNISTS

Columnists

Select David Aaronovitch Anjana Ahuja Chris AyresJoan BakewellSimon BarnesCherie BlairCamilla CavendishJeremy ClarksonRobert CramptonDaniel FinkelsteinMichael GoveSimon JenkinsRachel JohnsonAnatole KaletskyIndia KnightDominic LawsonRod LiddleMagnus LinklaterBen MacIntyreBronwen MaddoxMinette MarrinCarol MidgleyAlice MilesCaitlin MoranRichard MorrisonMatthew ParrisMichael PortilloLibby PurvesWilliam Rees-MoggMelanie ReidPeter RiddellHugo RifkindSathnam SangheraGraham StewartAndrew SullivanRachel SylvesterJanice TurnerGuest contributors

Blogs

Select Alpha Mummy Archive Blog David Aaronovitch Asia Exile Baby Barista Blockbuster Buzz Gerard Baker Charles Bremner Big Brother Mary Beard Comment Central Consumer Central Cricket Blog Eco Worrier Faith Central Fashion Formula One Ruth Gledhill Inside Iraq Ariel Leve India Knight Money Rafael Nadal News Blog William Rees-Mogg Rugby Sinofile Mick Smith Sports Commentary Irwin Stelzer Peter Stothard Surf Nation Technology Travel Urban dirt Video Wimbledon

Camilla Cavendish wins award for family justice campaign

Columns urging greater openness in family courts win Paul Foot Award

Cartoon More cartoons Peter Stothard

The Editor of the TLS writes on books, people and politics

A Don's Life

Mary Beard of Cambridge and the TLS on culture ancient and modern

Give that MP a raise!

Why it makes sense to pay politicians more

Comment Central Award-winning Iraq coverage from Deborah Haynes

A series on the plight of Iraqi interpreters took the Tony Bevins Prize for investigative journalism

MOST READ MOST COMMENTED MOST CURIOUS Most Read Skip Most Read Today Sri Lankan military shows 'body of Tamil... Claims of massacre as Tamil Tiger leaders die Honda Insight 1.3 IMA SE Hybrid Google challenged by new rival with all the... MOST COMMENTED Skip Editor's Pick Today Google challenged by new rival with all the... China banned child singer with crooked teeth... Public Duty and Private Vendetta Speaker Michael Martin on the brink as... MOST CURIOUS Skip Most Curious Today Sex theme park is G-string too far for China Colin the Movie, made by Marc Price for... Wine lovers can the bottle and turn to a... Gnomes infiltrate RHS Chelsea Flower Show... Focus Zone Northern Lights:

Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here

Business Solutions:

Risk, resilience and embracing new technology

Need to Know:

Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast

Business Wisdom:

Discover the collective power of smart thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Flip MinoHD Camcorder

Social Entrepreneurs:

The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors

Business Travel:

Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip

More reports:

Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more

Northern Lights Business Solutions Need to Know Business Wisdom Social Entrepreneurs Business Travel More reports Births, deaths, marriages

Place your announcement

Find a Lawyer

Cut your legal costs

Free CV Review

Sell yourself! Have your CV reviewed by experts

Crossword Club

Announcements

Search The Times Births, Marriages & Deaths

Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles

Classifieds Cars Jobs Property Travel Cars Skip Cars of the Week Motorati

Finding the best deal on a new car

BMW Bentley Continental Coupe

2005 51,850

Bugatti Veyron

£POA

Great car insurance deals online

Car Insurance

Search for more cars and bikes Jobs Skip Jobs of the Week Commercial Director

£150 k Mark Spiers and Associates UK

Progressive Management Opportunities

Attractive salary Waitrose London,South East & Southern England

Director of Strategy and Stakeholder Relations

from £70k upwards plus benefits, flexible PhonepayPlus South London

Chief Executive

Six Figure NSAP West Midlands

Search more Jobs Properties Looking to Buy? Looking to Sell? Kinleigh Folkard & Hayward

Completely London

Rushmore Condo's

Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views

South Africa - Cape Town

World Cup Investment Opp - 2 bed gated apartment

Octagon

Aspirational Homes from an Inspirational Company

Search for more properties Holidays Skip Travel of the Week Experience 14 nights in Tobago

With Golden Caribbean For just £619pp

Affordable Luxury

Experience Thailand from £1,580pp with Cleveland Collection

HOUSES OF PELION

S/c accomm in beautiful mainland Greece. Great offers for May and June

Travel insurance

Great travel insurance deals online .

Search for more holidays Place your advert now

Search Ad Reference:

Where am I?

Home Comment Columnists Guest contributors Contact us Back to top NewsCommentBusinessMoneySportLife & StyleTravelDrivingArts & EntsArchive OUR COLUMNISTS