Why Young Afghans Won't Vote

Oliver Mains, Global Post July 27, 2009

The grassroots protests that pitched Iran into political crisis serve as a reminder of the vital role that youth can play in leading a robust civil society. In neighboring Afghanistan, which will hold its own elections in less than a month, youth will choose not to engage despite their deep dissatisfaction with incompetent and corrupt governance.

Even at the American University of Afghanistan, where I teach international relations to students who constitute perhaps the country’s most politically aware demographic, apathy is in the air. Their desire for change is as palpable as ours was last November, but it is matched by pessimism toward their own power to influence Afghan politics.

For all the suspicion that fabrication of votes, bribing of election officials, intimidation, and worse will likely mar the August 20th election, Afghanistan’s internal problems are not what undermine my students’ zeal for civic participation. Why vote, my students ask me, when the United States will choose Afghanistan’s next president?

The truth is, while Afghanistan’s election will be a model of neither freedom nor fairness, the source of injustice will not be some grand American conspiracy. The Obama administration and its representatives in Afghanistan have a strong interest in ensuring that the elections are as transparent as Afghanistan’s fragile infrastructure and worsening security situation will allow, and have advertised their impartiality extensively. But in the end, the constant accusations of meddling are only a symptom of what is a much deeper public diplomacy problem.

Many of my students harbor a profound distrust of the United States. This was clear to me from the first days of the semester as students wondered aloud whether U.S. motivations in Afghanistan are driven by a desire to counter Russian and Chinese regional influence, to establish a puppet regime to ease the transit of oil through Central Asia, or simply to satisfy some neo-imperialist instinct. The source of this distrust is not some warlike Afghan nationalism, but growing anger toward continued insecurity combined with wildly exaggerated views toward American power.

To my students, America’s ability to project its military around the world, combined with its centrality in the creation and stewardship of international economic regimes, constitutes political omnipotence. When they ask themselves why insecurity persists and reconstruction languishes after eight years of American intervention, they conclude that America simply has no interest in Afghanistan’s development, and must instead be using its presence there to forward its global ambitions — whatever they may be.

No Comments.

Michael Moran - Worldview - July 26, 2009 10:10 ET

Think the global economic recovery is upon us? Here's what could postpone joy.

C.M. Sennott - Worldview - July 24, 2009 22:44 ET

As ambassador to Italy, David Thorne wants to improve America's image abroad.

Guest Writer - Worldview - July 23, 2009 21:23 ET

No strangers to struggle, they have been a driving force behind the Green Movement and on the front lines of post-election protests.

HDS Greenway - Worldview - July 20, 2009 20:44 ET

US risks harming friendly relations with its northern neighbor.

HDS Greenway - Worldview - July 19, 2009 16:36 ET

The roots of this week's violence go back. Way back.

Matt McAllester - Worldview - July 17, 2009 18:57 ET

But the khoresht fesenjan at this Persian restaurant is as good as in Iran.

HDS Greenway - Worldview - July 17, 2009 13:47 ET

So much for Obama's sunshine policy.

Brian L Frank - Worldview - July 16, 2009 08:10 ET

A photographer visits Mexico's most notorious barrios, where death is the only truth in life.

Brian L Frank - Worldview - July 13, 2009 13:06 ET

Robert Gilhooly - Worldview - July 10, 2009 18:52 ET

Jason Berry - Italy - July 9, 2009 14:07 ET

Benedict XVI leans to his left to greet the visiting president

Robert Gilhooly - Worldview - July 9, 2009 13:59 ET

Priests flagellate themselves with boiling water and walk across hot embers in a Shinto purification ritual.

Susan E. Reed - Worldview - July 7, 2009 13:07 ET

Opinion: The Obama administration wants to empower Ben Bernanke. Will it work?

Mort Rosenblum - Worldview - July 7, 2009 08:25 ET

Opinion: Hints of light in a not-so-dark continent

John Dyer - Europe-at-Large - July 6, 2009 19:21 ET

Meet Boyko Borisov: a former bodyguard and perhaps Bulgaria's next prime minister.

Michael Moran - Worldview - July 6, 2009 13:07 ET

Analysis: Sure, Obama and Medvedev are talking about the economy. Maybe they shouldn't be.

Joel Brinkley - Worldview - July 6, 2009 06:30 ET

Cambodians appreciate, even savor, the calm in their country, rather than worrying over the deprivation of their present-day lives.

Nermeen al-Mufti - Worldview - July 4, 2009 13:22 ET

After US withdrawal, Kirkuk's future murky even for fortune tellers

HDS Greenway - Worldview - July 4, 2009 08:26 ET

US forces in Afghanistan should keep in mind John Masters' account of the British campaign against the Pashtuns.

What we're hearing, including the world's top 6 trouble spots, Hillary Clinton focuses on North Korea, and a snake disrupts an Indian assembly.

Advertising on GlobalPost.comMore Dispatches:Latest

Breaking News:Latest

Why Young Afghans Won't Vote

Related Articles