Obama's Foreign Aid Mess

Michelle Goldberg, The Daily Beast August 17, 2009

The saintly, visionary public-health physician Paul Farmer is going to work for a Clinton—just not the one everyone expected. Until last week, Farmer was rumored to be Hillary Clinton’s choice to head USAID, the foreign-aid agency that has languished without a leader for almost seven months. Then he bowed out, and Wednesday came news that he’s going to be the U.N. Deputy Special Envoy to Haiti under Bill Clinton. It’s probably a much better position for him—Farmer isn’t a bureaucrat, and Haiti, where he founded the pioneering Zanmi Lasante hospital, is by all accounts where his heart is. But it raises a question that’s being asked with increasing urgency within development circles—why can’t the Obama administration fill the void at the top of USAID?

Foreign aid, after all, is a crucial part of the Obama administration’s ambitions for the globe. During the campaign, Barack Obama promised to double aid, and his entire approach to the world is based on emphasizing diplomacy and development in addition to military defense. As secretary of State, Hillary Clinton also pledged to make aid a priority. Speaking to USAID employees on her second day on the job, she said, “I wanted to come here today with a very simple message: I believe in development, and I believe with all my heart that it truly is an equal partner, along with defense and diplomacy, in the furtherance of America’s national security.” In Africa last week, she promoted aid for agricultural development as a “signature element” of the administration’s foreign policy.

Yet without leadership at USAID, not much progress can be made, and with Farmer out, it’s unclear who else is in the running. Among people who work on aid issues, impatience is giving way to disappointment and anger. “There was so much talk about how military might alone will not get us out of some of these armed conflicts that we’re involved in, and that we need to focus on civilian capacities. There was a lot of lip service to that,” says Amy Frumin, who served as USAID’s field officer in Afghanistan until two years ago. “By virtue of the fact that we haven’t appointed a new administrator, it seems we’re not taking action on that front.”

Even Hillary Clinton, who as secretary of State has always swallowed whatever disagreements she might have with the White House, spoke out last month. "The clearance and vetting process is a nightmare and it takes far longer than any of us would want to see," she told a meeting of USAID employees. “It is frustrating beyond words. I pushed very hard last week when I knew I was coming here to get permission from the White House to be able to tell you that help is on the way and someone will be nominated shortly…The message came back: 'We're not ready.'"

It’s possible to view the vacuum at USAID as symptomatic of tension between Clinton and Obama. Many people in the aid world speculate about the same list of possible candidates, some of them obviously Clinton people, others clearly associated with Obama. One name that often comes up is Wendy Sherman, who worked in Bill Clinton’s State Department and is now at the Albright Group, a firm founded by Madeleine Albright. Another is Gayle Smith, a former senior fellow at the Center for American Progress, and one of two leaders of the administration’s foreign-assistance transition team.

But the real problem in finding a leader for USAID goes deeper than mere rivalry.

The USAID that Obama inherited, almost everyone agrees, is a mess. It’s desperately in need of restructuring, and there are a number of plans in the works to do just that. But that means whomever is offered the job can’t quite know what they’re going to be leading.

Meanwhile, the vetting process for government officials has become preposterous. Among other things, candidates for the USAID post have to detail everywhere they’ve lived in their adult lives, and every foreign citizen they know—a particularly daunting prospect for people with lots of global experience. It’s as if it were designed to weed out anyone who hasn’t lived their entire life with a federal appointment in mind. It all adds up to a kind of case study of Washington dysfunction.

View as Single Page 12 Back to Top August 15, 2009 | 7:43pm Facebook | Twitter | | | Emails | print Foreign Aid, Usaid, Politics, Gayle Smith, Wendy Sherman, Usaid Leader, Paul Farmer Haiti, Hillary Clinton Foreign Aid, Hillary Clinton Usaid, Obama Foreign Aid, Obama Usaid, Barack Obama Foreign Aid, Paul Farmer, Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama (–) Show Replies Collapse Replies Sort Up Sort Down sort by date: alwaystry

Excellent comments. Foreign assistance with the USAID bureaucracy and the Department of State bureaucracy is like trying to run with two cinder blocks wired to your ankles.

Flag It | Permalink | Reply 6:28 pm, Aug 16, 2009 eeasyrider

Michelle, you never made a referance to USAID. Usually u are super smart. Without reference, I don't know what the hell you are talking about.

Flag It | Permalink | Reply 2:20 am, Aug 17, 2009 crymeariver

People can't have it both ways. You can't ask for high integrity in the Obama administration then complain when he puts up an intensive vetting process. If he chooses someone who happens to be associated with a foreign leader that we don't like, articles will be written about the "lack of" a good vetting process. I greatly admire Dr. Farmer's work, but I don't see him fitting in very well at state as a bureaucrat. What made his projects work was his ability to work as a renegade. He follows his own rules and makes new paths. He would be an excellent CONSULTANT but not the head of USAID. I am however happy to see an article addressing USAID, so thanks.

Flag It | Permalink | Reply 2:51 am, Aug 17, 2009 Gerry-

The following comments by PLANTAGENET on this article include THE 5 RULES OF PROPAGANDA. PLANTAGENT will demonstate the various ways in which propaganda can be inserted into a discussion. By using these examples and corresponding 5 RULES OF PROPAGANDA, you will be able to more readily identify what does and does not constitute propaganda. This will also help in determining your response to PLANTAGENET'S comments that contain propaganda, should you choose to reply. I hope you find PLANTAGENET'S comments and THE 5 RULES OF PROPAGANDA useful and informative. THE 5 RULES OF PROPAGANDA are as follows: 1) The rule of orchestration: endlessly repeating the same messages in different variations and combinations. 2) The rule of simplification: reducing all data to a simple confrontation between 'Good and Bad', 'Friend and Foe'. 3) The rule of disfiguration: discrediting the opposition by crude smears and parodies. 4) The rule of transfusion: manipulating the consensus values of the target audience for one's own ends. 5) The rule of unanimity: presenting one's viewpoint as if it were the unanimous opinion of all right-thinking people: draining the doubting individual into agreement by the appeal of star-performers, by social pressure, and by 'psychological contagion'.

Flag It | Permalink | Reply 3:20 am, Aug 17, 2009 $('#c_total span').html('4'); $('#c_total').show();

Thank you. As a first time user, your comment has been submitted for review. It can take anywhere from a few hours to a day or two for your comment to be reviewed, depending on the time of week and the volume of comments we receive.

Please log in to leave comments.

Madoff's Other Girlfriends by Lucinda FranksInfo

Lucinda Franks is a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist and author who was on the staff of the New York Times and has written for the New Yorker and the New York Times Book Review and Magazine. Her latest book is My Father's Secret War, about her father, who was a spy for the OSS during World War II.

X Close August 15, 2009 Summer of Hate by John AvlonInfo

John P. Avlon is the author of Independent Nation: How Centrists Can Change American Politics. He writes a weekly column for The Daily Beast. Previously, he served as Chief Speechwriter for New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani and was a columnist and associate editor for The New York Sun.

X Close August 13, 2009 Too Sexy for Italy? by Barbie Latza NadeauInfo

Barbie Latza Nadeau has reported from Italy for Newsweek Magazine since 1997. She also writes for CNN Traveller, Budget Travel Magazine and Frommer's.

X Close August 15, 2009 A Scandal Habit by Joseph FinderInfo

Joseph Finder is the New York Times bestselling author of numerous novels including Power Play, Killer Instinct, and Vanished (coming August 2009). Visit his Website.

X Close August 17, 2009 11 Most Awkward Dancing Stars by The Daily Beast VideoInfo

The Daily Beast Video curates the most essential and entertaining video, and brings you original and exclusive productions from our talented contributors.

X Close August 17, 2009 Why Are We in Afghanistan? by Benjamin SarlinInfo

Benjamin Sarlin is a reporter for The Daily Beast. He previously covered New York City politics for The New York Sun and has worked for talkingpointsmemo.com.

X Close August 17, 2009 Why the White Militias Are Back by Michelle GoldbergInfo

Michelle Goldberg is the author of The Means of Reproduction: Sex, Power and the Future of the World and Kingdom Coming: The Rise of Christian Nationalism. She is a senior correspondent for The American Prospect, and her work has appeared in The New Republic, The Nation, the Los Angeles Times, Glamour, and many other publications.

X Close August 13, 2009 The Health-Care Lie Machine by Michelle GoldbergInfo

X Close August 4, 2009 Too Hot for Fox News by Michelle GoldbergInfo

Sign me up for The Daily Beast's morning email and breaking news alerts.

Sign me up for The Yes List, weekly cultural recommendations from The Daily Beast.

I'd like to recieve e-mail notifications as:

Text Only HTML

Sign me up for occasional special offers sent by The Daily Beast on behalf of select sponsors, and for occasional special offers from IAC companies.

X Close Please register to manage your email preferences and comment on the site.

Read Full Article »

Comment

Show comments

Obama's Foreign Aid Mess

Related Articles