Europe vs. Russia's Energy Weapon

Uffe Ellemann-Jensen, Daily Star December 10, 2009

As winter approaches, many people in Central and Eastern Europe remember the chill caused last winter by Russia’s deliberate cut-off of gas supplies. That shutdown was a harsh reminder that gas is now the Kremlin’s primary political instrument as it seeks to re-establish its privileged sphere of interest in what it thinks of as Russia’s “near-abroad.” If Russia is allowed to continuing imposing Moscow rules on Europe’s energy supplies, the result will be costly – not only for Europe, but for Russia as well.

So it is past time that the European Union stopped treating energy as a bilateral issue, with some of the larger member states trying to protect their own narrow interests at the expense of the common European good. The EU urgently needs to build a common energy policy and a single market for natural gas. Until both are established, there is a grave risk that Russia will use new blockades to continue the kind of divide-and-rule policy that the world has witnessed since Vladimir Putin came to power.

The planned Nord Stream gas pipeline on the bottom of the Baltic Sea is a good example of the problems that everyone in Europe is facing. The pipeline has been established as a Russian-German-Dutch consortium, but it is the Russian energy giant Gazprom that is in the driver’s seat with 51 percent of the shares. Nord Stream will enable Russia to deliver natural gas directly to Germany without using the existing land-based connections.

At first glance, there seems to be no problem. But the real reason that Russia wants to build Nord Stream – which is more expensive than the existing gas-pipeline network – is that it will enable it to interrupt gas supplies to European Union member countries like Poland, the Baltic states, and other neighbors like Ukraine, while keeping its German and other West European customers snug and warm.

Countries that have good reason to fear a Russian manufactured chill have loudly proclaimed that Nord Stream is politically rather than economically motivated. After all, it would be much cheaper to expand existing land pipelines than to build undersea. Moreover, Russia’s ability to meet future gas demand from commercially viable reserves suggests that Nord Stream could be used to cut off gas sales to unfavored clients.

Yet these concerns have been pushed aside by the powerful pro-Nord Stream lobby, led by the former German chancellor Gerhard Schroeder, who, having approved Nord Stream while in office, was quickly hired by Gazprom as a representative after he left it. In most democracies, such a move would have quickly received prosecutorial attention. But no serious investigation of the propriety of Schroeder’s dealings was ever launched, perhaps because of the scale and importance of German-Russian economic ties.

This November, Nord Stream was given a surprising go-ahead by three Scandinavian countries that will lend their seabed to the project: Denmark, Sweden, and Finland. They seem to regard the case as a “technical issue,” and are now satisfied because environmental guarantees have been given.

But the Nord Stream pipeline is no “technical issue.” The concerns of countries that fear being left out in the cold must be addressed, which is why it is necessary to establish a single European Union market for natural gas. That way, no one would be left exposed to Russian pressure.

Europe undoubtedly needs Russian gas, but fears that this gives Russia a monopolistic stranglehold over Europe are exaggerated. Russia’s share of total EU gas imports is just above 40 percent today, compared to 80 percent in 1980. Moreover, Russian gas represents only 6-7 percent of the EU’s total primary energy supply.

So, in general, dependence on Russian gas should not be feared. The problem is that some countries in the eastern part of the EU are much more dependent on Russian gas than the average figures suggest. Thus, they must be guaranteed the kind of solidarity that is fundamental to EU membership.

Last year’s experience with interrupted gas supplies did have one benefit: new life was blown into plans for alternative routes, like the Nabucco pipeline that is to bring Azeri gas to Europe through Turkey. An early warning system on potential supply cuts has also been agreed between Russia and the EU. And it looks like Ukraine’s Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko has charmed Prime Minister Vladimir Putin into concluding a new gas deal. Yet anxiety remains high in the countries most exposed to new supply cuts.

It is in Russia’s own interest that the EU deal with it as a united entity. Continued fear and uncertainty about Russian gas supplies would undoubtedly lead the most exposed European Union countries to seek to protect themselves by blocking EU-Russia negotiations on new partnership and cooperation agreements.

In his State of the Nation speech this November, Russian President Dmitri Medvedev stressed the need for modernization of the Russian economy. Closer cooperation with the EU is the most obvious way to make this possible. But, so long as Russia is perceived as an energy blackmailer and not a partner, such cooperation will be impossible.

Uffe Ellemann-Jensen is a former Danish foreign minister. THE DAILY STAR publishes this commentary in collaboration with Project Syndicate © (www.project-syndicate.org).

var server_client_id = 2074; var server_ad_width = 468; var server_ad_height = 60; var server_ad_style = "468x60_as"; var server_code_version = "4"; var server_ad_color_border = "7E8AA2"; var server_ad_color_background = "FFFFFF"; var server_ad_color_headline = "7E8AA2"; var server_ad_color_body = "000000"; var server_ad_color_url = "666EBA"; var server_ad_keyword = ""; var server_ad_channel = 18; var server_publisher_channels = ""; var server_ad_random = 1; var server_target = "1"; Tags: Energy, Europe, European Union, German, Russia, States

Printable Version Send to a friend Listen to the Article addthis_url = location.href; addthis_title = document.title; addthis_pub = 'dailystar';

Your feedback is important to us! We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Click here NOW to Comment on this Article

More Opinion Articles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . »Barack Obama would do better to show the fire inside »Can the Maronites reinvent themselves? »Europe may add little on the Iranian nuclear standoff »Looking back on recent cycles of economic discontent »The refugees, still essential to peace »Salam Fayyad may save Israel from the occupation quagmire »Envy was at the heart of Switzerland's anti-minaret vote »One woman embarrasses Madrid and Rabat »Thailand's Muslim separatists wage a much-ignored war »Lebanon's latest government: a perspective from Israel »Pakistan must benefit from a US bill »While the US fights, Afghanistan's neighbors do far better

For a new Star Scene experience, check our new website at http://starscene.dailystar.com.lb

Copyright © 2009, The Daily Star. All rights reserved. Click here to contact our syndication department for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material. Contact the Online editor to report any problems with the site or to send your comments and suggestions. var sc_project=731379; var sc_invisible=1; var sc_partition=6; var sc_security="3de32f75"; LEBANON NEWS Politics. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .» Sectarianism, Hizbullah's arms top debate at Parliament» Celebrating diversity on Human Rights Day» Aoun pays visit to Assad, urges greater bilateral cooperationBusiness. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .» Hong Kong offers incentives to Lebanese companies» EIU forecasts Lebanon's real GDP growth at 5.8 percent in 2010» Lebanon's Solidere unit eyes Saudi Arabia, Montenegro -- More Lebanon News -- _uacct = "UA-360006-1"; urchinTracker();

Printable Version Send to a friend Listen to the Article

Your feedback is important to us! We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Click here NOW to Comment on this Article

For a new Star Scene experience, check our new website at http://starscene.dailystar.com.lb

Your feedback is important to us! We invite all our readers to share with us their views and comments about this article.

Click here NOW to Comment on this Article

For a new Star Scene experience, check our new website at http://starscene.dailystar.com.lb

Read Full Article »

Comment

Show comments

Europe vs. Russia's Energy Weapon

Related Articles