Remember Iraq? For months our attention has been focused on Afghanistan, and you can be sure that the surge will be covered exhaustively as it unfolds in 2010. But the coming year could be even more pivotal in Iraq. The country will hold elections in March to determine its political future. Months of parliamentary horse trading will likely ensue, which could provoke a return to violence. The United States still has 120,000 troops stationed in Iraq, and all combat forces are scheduled to leave by August, further testing the country's ability to handle its own security. How we draw down in Iraq is just as critical as how we ramp up in Afghanistan: If handled badly, this withdrawal could be a disaster. Handled well, it could leave behind a significant success.
Let's review some history. The surge in Iraq was a success in military terms. It defeated a nasty insurgency, reduced violence substantially, and stabilized the country. But the purpose of the surge was, in President Bush's formulation, to give Iraq's leaders a chance to resolve their major political differences. It was these differences"”particularly between Sunnis and Shias"”that were fueling the civil war in the first place. If they were not resolved, the war might well begin anew or take some other form that would doom Iraq to a breakup or breakdown.
Iraq's political differences have not been resolved. The most fraught remains the tussle between the Shias, the country's majority sect, and the Sunnis, a minority that has traditionally been the country's elite. The simplest indication that issues between these two communities are still unsettled is the fact that only a few of the 2 million Iraqis who fled the country between 2003 and 2007"”the vast majority of whom were Sunnis"”have returned. (Firm numbers are hard to come by, but they did not add up to more than a few tens of thousands as of this summer.) This month the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees reaffirmed that Iraq remains a dangerous place for members of minority groups, and that they should therefore not be forced to return to Iraq.
Sunnis in Iraq remain marginalized politically. And there are growing tensions with the Kurds, who run an autonomous quasi state in Iraq's north. The Kurds control three of Iraq's provinces but lay claim to three important cities just across the border that have mixed populations. They have also been flouting the central government's authority regarding oil contracts, negotiating 30 separate deals of their own and blocking the flow of oil out of the Kurdish region. Add to these problems disputes over the drawing of boundaries and election rules.
The basic challenge is simple to state but extremely difficult to meet. Iraq needs a stable power-sharing deal that keeps all three groups invested in the new country. To make this happen, all three will need to compromise. And the central positive force in all of this can be the United States. In the early years of the occupation, the Bush administration never pushed the Iraqi government enough to force it to cut deals. This was a historic error because the U.S. had enormous political leverage with the Iraqis at the time. Even later, the Bush administration shied away from pressing the Iraqis too hard, a common thread in its relations with the Afghans and Pakistanis, too.
Yet the United States continues to have considerable influence in Iraq. By all accounts, U.S. diplomacy has been crucial to getting the Kurds to agree to the March elections. President Obama is reported to have called Kurdish leader Massoud Barzani and pressed him to withdraw his objections, removing the final obstacle. As American troops draw down, American diplomacy should get aggressive and persistent, pushing the three groups to resolve the basic issues of power sharing.
The costs of the Iraq war have been great and perhaps indefensible. But Iraq could still turn out to be an extraordinary model for the Arab world. Its people are negotiating their differences for the most part peacefully; its politics is becoming more pluralistic and democratic; its press is free; its provinces have autonomy; its focus has shifted to business and wealth creation, not religion and jihad. The Obama administration has a window of opportunity to cement these gains in 2010.
Fareed Zakaria is editor of NEWSWEEK International and author of The Post-American World andThe Future of Freedom: Illiberal Democracy at Home and Abroad.
© 2010
Presented By placeAd2("module/take/article",'88x31',false,''); My Take
Each Newsweek reader is different"”and now your Newsweek can be, too. Use this page to create a experience that's personalized for you and your interests. My Take: it makes Newsweek whatever you want it to be.
Check the boxes below to keep track of your favorite Newsweek voices: Select columnists below Previous Next JonMeacham unchecked FareedZakaria unchecked JonathanAlter unchecked JuliaBaird unchecked SharonBegley unchecked EleanorClift unchecked EllisCose unchecked ChristopherDickey unchecked HowardFineman unchecked DanielGross unchecked MichaelHirsh unchecked MarkHosenball unchecked MichaelIsikoff unchecked BarbaraKantrowitz unchecked PatWingert unchecked RainaKelley unchecked DahliaLithwick unchecked DanielLyons unchecked LisaMiller unchecked Robert J.Samuelson unchecked SteveTuttle unchecked JacobWeisberg unchecked George F.Will unchecked Clear Share: Facebook Digg Tweet LinkedIn newsweek:http://www.newsweek.com/id/227584 Tools: 5 Post Your Comment Print Email NWK.widget.EmailArticle.init(); SPONSORED BY placeAd2('printthis','88x31|3',false,''); Label Relive the Decade
One photo per month, from 2000 to 2009.
10 Who Died Too Soon
People we lost in the 2000s.
Jobbed
How America works now. The latest on employment and careers.
Odd Jobs for Big Bucks
Strange careers that can bring in six-figure salaries.
var url = 'http://content.pulse360.com/ECC45BD6-867E-11DE-8C30-D41FEDADD848'; url += '?CommercialNode=' + commercialNode; // NOTE :: The "scr" + "ipt" break is essential, presumably to bypass loose // js/DOM safeguards against doing what we want to do here. document.write('"); var isAuthenticated = false; Discuss Enter Your Comment NWK.widget.CommentsSubmit.form = $('#comment-form'); NWK.widget.CommentsSubmit.init(); placeAd2('comments/'+commercialNode,'88x31|2',false,''); Sponsored by Member Comments Reply Report Abuse Posted By: gregcovert @ 12/19/2009 8:42:12 PM
Vig, Stop the nonsense, o.k? Have a Merry Christmas and a happy New Year. Maybe 2010 will bring you some peace. You seem to need some.
Reply Report Abuse Posted By: Vigilance @ 12/19/2009 7:36:14 PM
And when I say "the hatred of violence" - I mean the desire to see violence done as a way to satisfy unjust hatreds.Perhaps "a love of violence" would actually be more a more accurate phrase to describe the worse aspects of American culture.
Reply Report Abuse Posted By: Vigilance @ 12/19/2009 7:33:37 PM
Sad that America will jail and kill others for supposed sex offenses yet completely ignore the presence of violence against our own in our midst...but that is the national identity. The hatred of violence is seen as a form of love, and yet acts of physical love are frequently seen as a criminal form of psychological violence. I think it's a sign of the cowardice of my nation in some ways - people will not open their hearts, but they will cheerfully open their wallets to kill foreigners in order to satisfy a bloodlust masquerading as patriotism. I love my country, but it makes me sick to see.
Reply Enter Your Comment Report Abuse
Enter comments if any for reporting abuse
Report Abuse View All Comments » NWK.widget.CommentsReply.init(); NWK.widget.CommentsReport.init(); placeAd2(commercialNode,'articleFlex',false,'') My Take placeAd2("module/take",'88x31',false,''); Sponsored By:
Customize the NEWSWEEK homepage to feature your favorite columnists.
Customize Now var flashvars = {}; var params = {}; var attributes = {}; params.allowScriptAccess = "always"; params.wmode = "transparent"; flashvars.channel = "World"; flashvars.nw = "t"; flashvars.env = "prod"; flashvars.omnitureAccount = "wpninewsweekprod"; flashvars.pageType = "SP"; flashvars.fileLoc = "http://ndn1.newsweek.com/site/redesign/flash/most-popular/"; if (hasFlash("swfTopTenVertical")) swfobject.embedSWF("http://ndn1.newsweek.com/site/redesign/flash/most-popular/top10_smallKernel.swf", "swfTopTenVertical", "331", "220", "8.0.0", "http://ndn2.newsweek.com/site/redesign/js/libs/swf/expressInstall.swf", flashvars, params, attributes); placeAd2(commercialNode,'300x100',false,'') var url = 'http://content.pulse360.com/AFA28B5A-4F8E-11DE-882C-6423EDADD848'; url += '?CommercialNode=c_col_' + commercialNode; // NOTE :: The "scr" + "ipt" break is essential, presumably to bypass loose // js/DOM safeguards against doing what we want to do here. document.write('"); .container { border-top:2px solid #999; width:350px; font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif; background-image: url(http://ndn3.newsweek.com/site/redesign/images/inTheKnow/bg-gray-gradient.jpg); background-repeat: repeat-x; } .container img { border:none; float:right; } .digg { margin:0 0 30px 5px; overflow:hidden; padding-left: 5px; } .digg h3 { font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif!important; color:#000; font-size:14px!important; padding:12px 0 12px 0; text-transform:uppercase; } .diggs { color:#336599; float:left; height:30px; line-height:30px; margin-left:10px; padding-right:10px; width:32px; } .digg-article { border-bottom:1px solid #999; overflow:hidden; padding-bottom:7px; } .digg ul { overflow:hidden; padding-bottom:9px; padding-top:14px; list-style:none; } .digg ul li { clear:left; overflow:hidden; padding:8px 0 0; } .digg ul li img { padding-right:6px; } .digg .text { float:left; font-size:1.2em; line-height:1.25; padding-bottom:5px; width:200px; } .digg-count { background-image: url(http://ndn2.newsweek.com/media/34/digg-bg.png)!important; background-repeat:no-repeat!important; background-position:left !important; float:left; color:#000 !important; height:30px; line-height:30px; margin-right:0 !important; padding-right:10px; text-decoration:none !important; width:32px; font-size:11px!important; text-align:center !important; } .digg-ajax h3 a { color:#900 !important; font-size:12px !important; line-height:16px !important; text-decoration:none !important; text-transform:none !important; vertical-align:center !important; } .digg-ajax h3 a:hover { text-decoration:underline!important; } .digg-ajax ul { padding-bottom:2px !important; padding-top:0 !important; } .digg-ajax li { border-top:1px solid #ccc; padding:8px 0 !important; } .digg-ajax li a span { display:none !important; } .digg-footer { border-top: 1px solid #ccc; padding-top:8px; width: 330px; } Newsweek on Digg digg_id = 'digg-widget-container'; //make this id unique for each widget you put on a single page. digg_width = '330px'; digg_height = 'auto'; digg_border = 0; digg_theme = 'digg-widget-unstyled'; digg_title = 'Popular stories from the source site newsweek.com sorted by dates'; Previous Next
Read Full Article »