Two schools of thought have traditionally competed to determine how America should approach the world. Realists believe we should care most about what states do beyond their borders"”that influencing their foreign policy ought to be Washington's priority. Neoconservatives often contend the opposite: they argue that what matters most is the nature of other countries, what happens inside their borders. The neocons believe this both for moral reasons and because democracies (at least mature ones) treat their neighbors better than do authoritarian regimes.
I am a card-carrying realist on the grounds that ousting regimes and replacing them with something better is easier said than done. I also believe that Washington, in most cases, doesn't have the luxury of trying. The United States must, for example, work with undemocratic China to rein in North Korea and with autocratic Russia to reduce each side's nuclear arsenal. This debate is anything but academic. It's at the core of what is likely to be the most compelling international story of 2010: Iran.
In the wake of 9/11, the Bush administration judged incorrectly that Iran was on the verge of revolution and decided that dealing directly with Tehran would provide a lifeline to an evil government soon to be swept away by history's tide. A valuable opportunity to limit Iran's nuclear program may have been lost as a result. The incoming Obama administration reversed this approach and expressed a willingness to talk to Iran without preconditions. This president (like George H.W. Bush, whose emissaries met with Chinese leaders soon after Tiananmen Square) is cut more from the realist cloth. Diplomacy and negotiations are seen not as favors to bestow but as tools to employ. The other options"”using military force against Iranian nuclear facilities or living with an Iranian nuclear bomb"”were judged to be tremendously unattractive. And if diplomacy failed, Obama reasoned, it would be easier to build domestic and international support for more robust sanctions. At the time, I agreed with him.
I've changed my mind. The nuclear talks are going nowhere. The Iranians appear intent on developing the means to produce a nuclear weapon; there is no other explanation for the secret uranium-enrichment facility discovered near the holy city of Qum. Fortunately, their nuclear program appears to have hit some technical snags, which puts off the need to decide whether to launch a preventive strike. Instead we should be focusing on another fact: Iran may be closer to profound political change than at any time since the revolution that ousted the shah 30 years ago.
The authorities overreached in their blatant manipulation of last June's presidential election, and then made matters worse by brutally repressing those who protested. Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei has lost much of his legitimacy, as has the "elected" president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. The opposition Green Movement has grown larger and stronger than many predicted.
The United States, European governments, and others should shift their Iran policy toward increasing the prospects for political change. Leaders should speak out for the Iranian people and their rights. President Obama did this on Dec. 28 after several protesters were killed on the Shia holy day of Ashura, and he should do so again. So should congressional and world leaders. Iran's Revolutionary Guards should be singled out for sanctions. Lists of their extensive financial holdings can be published on the Internet. The United States should press the European Union and others not to trade or provide financing to selected entities controlled by the Guards. Just to cite one example: the Revolutionary Guards now own a majority share of Iran's principal telecommunications firm; no company should furnish it the technology to deny or monitor Internet use.
New funding for the project housed at Yale University that documents human-rights abuses in Iran is warranted. If the U.S. government won't reverse its decision not to provide the money, then a foundation or wealthy individuals should step in. Such a registry might deter some members of the Guards or the million-strong Basij militia it controls from attacking or torturing members of the opposition. And even if not, the gesture will signal to Iranians that the world is taking note of their struggle.
placeAd2(commercialNode,'bigbox',false,'')
It is essential to bolster what people in Iran know. Outsiders can help to provide access to the Internet, the medium that may be the most important means for getting information into Iran and facilitating communication among the opposition. The opposition also needs financial support from the Iranian diaspora so that dissidents can stay politically active once they have lost their jobs.
Just as important as what to do is what to avoid. Congressmen and senior administration figures should avoid meeting with the regime. Any and all help for Iran's opposition should be nonviolent. Iran's opposition should be supported by Western governments, not led. In this vein, outsiders should refrain from articulating specific political objectives other than support for democracy and an end to violence and unlawful detention. Sanctions on Iran's gasoline imports and refining, currently being debated in Congress, should be pursued at the United Nations so international focus does not switch from the illegality of Iran's behavior to the legality of unilateral American sanctions. Working-level negotiations on the nuclear question should continue. But if there is an unexpected breakthrough, Iran's reward should be limited. Full normalization of relations should be linked to meaningful reform of Iran's politics and an end to Tehran's support of terrorism.
Critics will say promoting regime change will encourage Iranian authorities to tar the opposition as pawns of the West. But the regime is already doing so. Outsiders should act to strengthen the opposition and to deepen rifts among the rulers. This process is underway, and while it will take time, it promises the first good chance in decades to bring about an Iran that, even if less than a model country, would nonetheless act considerably better at home and abroad. Even a realist should recognize that it's an opportunity not to be missed.
Haass, president of The Council on Foreign Relations, is author of War of Necessity, War of Choice: A Memoir of Two Iraq Wars.
© 2010
Share: Facebook Digg Tweet LinkedIn newsweek:http://www.newsweek.com/id/231991 Tools: 8 Post Your Comment Print Email NWK.widget.EmailArticle.init(); SPONSORED BY placeAd2('printthis','88x31|3',false,''); Label Obama's First Year
Video: Watch the president's approval rating and the country's mood change over 12 months.
Faces of Tragedy
Images of Haiti's earthquake victims and rescuers.
Who Deserves Blame By Howard Fineman
Analyzing the Democrats' shocking loss in Massachussetts.
Google's Battle With China By Fareed Zakaria
The search giant tests Beijing's appetite for democracy.
placeAd2(commercialNode,'below_story',false,'') var url = 'http://content.pulse360.com/ECC45BD6-867E-11DE-8C30-D41FEDADD848'; url += '?CommercialNode=' + commercialNode; // NOTE :: The "scr" + "ipt" break is essential, presumably to bypass loose // js/DOM safeguards against doing what we want to do here. document.write('"); var isAuthenticated = false; Discuss Enter Your Comment NWK.widget.CommentsSubmit.form = $('#comment-form'); NWK.widget.CommentsSubmit.init(); placeAd2('comments/'+commercialNode,'88x31|2',false,''); Sponsored by Member Comments Reply Report Abuse Posted By: Procivic @ 01/23/2010 3:19:09 AM
It's not clear whether Richard Haas is concerned about the nuclear issue or human rights. If the former, he should know better than most that, unlike some of America's current and erstwhile friends, Iran signed the NPT back in 1968 and the IAEA has found no diversion of nuclear material for weaponization.If he is primarily concerned with human rights, Mr. Haas should first direct his attention to Washington???s allies with which the U.S. has political leverage: Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Jordan, etc. But the world won't hold its breath while this "card-carrying realist" continues to change his mind.
Reply Report Abuse Posted By: Banafsheh @ 01/23/2010 1:57:58 AM
Good to see Mr. Haass has FINALLY accepted this fact. I was in the meeting held by Mr. Haass, Brzezinski and Gates in July 2004 when the 3 gentlemen sat in the DC CFR and insisted that negotiations must go on. So far CFR has been a rather stalwart and unfortunate source of problems for the Iranian opposition and the fact that Mr. Haass calls himself is a realist is in the view of many of us Iranians who have tried to get American and international career politicos to see this is an humorous overstatement. But, I suppose, better late than never. Let's hope that now, CFR learns it's place where Iran and Iranians are concerned.
Reply Report Abuse Posted By: Banafsheh @ 01/23/2010 1:57:54 AM
Good to see Mr. Haass has FINALLY accepted this fact. I was in the meeting held by Mr. Haass, Brzezinski and Gates in July 2004 when the 3 gentlemen sat in the DC CFR and insisted that negotiations must go on. So far CFR has been a rather stalwart and unfortunate source of problems for the Iranian opposition and the fact that Mr. Haass calls himself is a realist is in the view of many of us Iranians who have tried to get American and international career politicos to see this is an humorous overstatement. But, I suppose, better late than never. Let's hope that now, CFR learns it's place where Iran and Iranians are concerned.
Reply Enter Your Comment Report Abuse
Enter comments if any for reporting abuse
Report Abuse View All Comments » NWK.widget.CommentsReply.init(); NWK.widget.CommentsReport.init(); placeAd2(commercialNode,'articleFlex',false,'') var flashvars = {}; var params = {}; var attributes = {}; params.allowScriptAccess = "always"; params.wmode = "transparent"; flashvars.channel = "World"; flashvars.nw = "t"; flashvars.env = "prod"; flashvars.omnitureAccount = "wpninewsweekprod"; flashvars.pageType = "SP"; flashvars.fileLoc = "http://ndn1.newsweek.com/site/redesign/flash/most-popular/"; if (hasFlash("swfTopTenVertical")) swfobject.embedSWF("http://ndn1.newsweek.com/site/redesign/flash/most-popular/top10_smallKernel.swf", "swfTopTenVertical", "331", "220", "8.0.0", "http://ndn2.newsweek.com/site/redesign/js/libs/swf/expressInstall.swf", flashvars, params, attributes); var url = 'http://content.pulse360.com/AFA28B5A-4F8E-11DE-882C-6423EDADD848'; url += '?CommercialNode=c_col_' + commercialNode; // NOTE :: The "scr" + "ipt" break is essential, presumably to bypass loose // js/DOM safeguards against doing what we want to do here. document.write('"); .container { border-top:2px solid #999; width:350px; font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif; background-image: url(http://ndn3.newsweek.com/site/redesign/images/inTheKnow/bg-gray-gradient.jpg); background-repeat: repeat-x; } .container img { border:none; float:right; } .digg { margin:0 0 30px 5px; overflow:hidden; padding-left: 5px; } .digg h3 { font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif!important; color:#000; font-size:14px!important; padding:12px 0 12px 0; text-transform:uppercase; } .diggs { color:#336599; float:left; height:30px; line-height:30px; margin-left:10px; padding-right:10px; width:32px; } .digg-article { border-bottom:1px solid #999; overflow:hidden; padding-bottom:7px; } .digg ul { overflow:hidden; padding-bottom:9px; padding-top:14px; list-style:none; } .digg ul li { clear:left; overflow:hidden; padding:8px 0 0; } .digg ul li img { padding-right:6px; } .digg .text { float:left; font-size:1.2em; line-height:1.25; padding-bottom:5px; width:200px; } .digg-count { background-image: url(http://ndn2.newsweek.com/media/34/digg-bg.png)!important; background-repeat:no-repeat!important; background-position:left !important; float:left; color:#000 !important; height:30px; line-height:30px; margin-right:0 !important; padding-right:10px; text-decoration:none !important; width:32px; font-size:11px!important; text-align:center !important; } .digg-ajax h3 a { color:#900 !important; font-size:12px !important; line-height:16px !important; text-decoration:none !important; text-transform:none !important; vertical-align:center !important; } .digg-ajax h3 a:hover { text-decoration:underline!important; } .digg-ajax ul { padding-bottom:2px !important; padding-top:0 !important; } .digg-ajax li { border-top:1px solid #ccc; padding:8px 0 !important; } .digg-ajax li a span { display:none !important; } .digg-footer { border-top: 1px solid #ccc; padding-top:8px; width: 330px; } Newsweek on Digg digg_id = 'digg-widget-container'; //make this id unique for each widget you put on a single page. digg_width = '330px'; digg_height = 'auto'; digg_border = 0; digg_theme = 'digg-widget-unstyled'; digg_title = 'Popular stories from the source site newsweek.com sorted by dates'; var config = new Object(); config["divid"] = "brightcove30256"; config["type"] = "mini_standard"; config["configpid"] = "1243489057"; config["rsspid"] = "1137883278"; config["rsslid"] = "1137849353"; config["titleid"] = "62378892001"; config["numItems"] = "5"; config["lineupCollapse"] = "true"; config["lineupName"] = "MORE VIDEO"; config["videoPreview"] = "false"; config["autoStart"] = "false"; config["width"] = 336; config["height"] = 390; config["styleclass"] = "brightcove-mini-player"; config["activeTab"] = "video"; config["bgColor"] = "#FFFFFF"; config["url"] = "30256"; if (typeof(commercialNode) != 'undefined') config["commercialNode"] = commercialNode; if (typeof(commercialNode) != 'undefined') placeAd2("video/"+commercialNode,'video',false,''); bcFullscreenPlayer(config); Previous Next 01/11 - 01/17 News/Week A Tough Case at Abortion Doc's Murder Trial Why the Gay Marriage Trial Should Be Public Can the Greenbrier Resort Be Saved? Health-Care Reform a Political Liability for Democrats Obama's Terror Policies Could Be Riding on Mass. Senate Race Why Liberals Thrive in Crises President Obama: Why Haiti Matters How American Churches Are Helping in Haiti How Cities Rebuild from Disaster Is the Obama Administration Running Detroit? Clash of the Titans: Google vs. China The Risks of Person-to-Person Lending Backstage at the 2010 Golden Globes The Opening of the Academic Mind The Golden Globes's Most Embarrassing Moments Why Heidi Montag's Plastic Surgery Disturbs Us How Women Can Get More Sleep Swine Flu Death Toll Passes 11,000 NWK.widget.NewsSlashWeek.init(); placeAd2(commercialNode,'rightSidePromo',false,'') Haiti ends search for quake survivors Celebrities unite to help Haiti in telethon "�Guys and Dolls' actress Jean Simmons dies O'Brien on final show: "�I do not regret a second' U.K. raises terror threat level to "�severe' Populist backlash puts Fed chief under siege Democrats left with few options Poll: Voter anger drove GOP win O'Brien exits with jokes, grace Rhee: Ex-teachers abused kids Slate V: Obama's First Year: Hell in a Handbasket How Obama's cool, detached temperament is hurting him and his party. What happens when a charity receives too many donations? The misguided theories behind Citizens United v. FEC. The Slatest: Evening Edition US Admiral: Aid Distribution 'Stymied' Undocumented Haitians Can Stay in US Fort Hood Probe Exposes Shortfalls Tylenol Recall Expanded Over Odor Deal Struck on Health Care Tax Apple Hates Porn. But Porn Loves the iPhone. An Exchange on Prosper.com What If You Asked a Financial Question, and No One Answered? A Note to Our Readers China Slaps Back at Google Readers' best reflection photos Park your RV for free in New Zealand San Francisco: Get a taxi with your iPhone Readers' Choice: Favorite national park? TSA 'humor': Where'd you get this baggie of white powder, miss? About NewsweekAdvertising InformationSubscriber ServicesPressroomContact UsUser AgreementPrivacy PolicyJobsBack CopiesRights and Reprint SalesShowcase AdsSitemap© 2010 Newsweek, Inc. They ... can be bombed Petraeus, on contingency plans for a nuclear IranTELEGRAPH It's the Taliban I'm afraid of Afghan woman, on why she wears the burqa in publicABC Bodies.Bodies.Bodies Bodies.Bodies.Bodies. Richard Morse, in a tweet from HaitiPALM I remember...thinking 'Someday, I'm going to host that show for seven months ConanFORBES
Read Full Article »