Comments: 1
Last Updated: 9:59 AM, January 31, 2010
Posted: 12:36 AM, January 31, 2010
The motto for United States humanitarian relief efforts around the world, most recently in Haiti, should be “damned if you do, and damned if you don’t.” However much or little America contributes, someone complains, from those who think we unfairly have to shoulder a disproportionate share of the world’s disaster relief to those who think our response smacks of imperialism.
America’s long-dominant role in international relief reflects both America’s innate compassion and its status as the world’s sole superpower. Time and time again, from tropical-storm devastation in Bangladesh, to the Dec. 26, 2004, tsunami in Indonesia, to last month’s earthquake in Haiti, it is America that steps forward first to provide humanitarian relief. In particular, the US military has repeatedly brought to bear its enormous logistical capabilities, especially to lead the immediate response to both natural and man-made disasters.
sports_page quigo_lower 1482096 871776 440 225 * -->And what distinguishes the United States even more from other countries is the consistently generous responses by millions of individual citizens, not waiting for their government to act, but contributing money, resources and their own time through churches, fraternal organizations and charities. We don’t do this because we have to, but because we want to. For good reason, therefore, we rightly view ourselves as well-motivated, effective and openhanded.
Many foreigners disagree. Just days after Haiti’s earthquake, France’s minister for international cooperation, Alain Joyandet, complained about the US effort, notably our military’s control of Haiti’s main airport. Joyandet said that “this is about helping Haiti, not about occupying Haiti.” Fortunately, France’s president, Nicolas Sarkozy, whipped his minister back into line, just in time before Americans started reminding Paris of France’s colonial legacy in Haiti. Nonetheless, Europe, even after several weeks, is far from matching the US response.
Many people ask why, instead of the United States invariably taking on the burden of “first responder” to humanitarian disaster, the United Nations shouldn’t handle the job. Indeed, in the case of Haiti, there were approximately 9,000 UN uniformed peacekeepers already posted there, as well as almost 2,000 civilian UN personnel. Unfortunately, the UN’s performance over the years demonstrates it is not up to the task. In Haiti, even worse, scores of UN personnel died in the earthquake, including Hedi Annabi, the head of the overall UN mission in country.
The UN’s own internal disorganization has long made fast and effective responses almost impossible. Numerous independently governed and administered UN agencies and programs are involved in humanitarian relief efforts, and each marches to its own drummer. UNICEF cares for children and families; the World Health Organization looks after health, sanitation and medicines; the World Food Program distributes food supplies; and the UN High Commissioner for Refugees provides protection and assistance when political or natural disasters cause large numbers of people to cross national borders. The UN Development Program is supposed to be the overall country coordinator of the work of the many agencies involved, but that’s a nearly impossible task.
Then, of course, there’s the long, well-documented history of waste, fraud, corruption and incompetence in UN programs. In Haiti just last week, for example, UN peacekeeping troops from Uruguay were unable to manage the orderly distribution of food (donated from the US, of course) even directly in front of the Port-au-Prince’s now-leveled Presidential Palace. No criticisms, however, from Paris.
The UN system’s dysfunctional performance over the years culminated in dismay over the handling of refugees and displaced persons when Saddam Hussein renewed his persecution of Kurds and Shi’ites after the 1991 Persian Gulf War. Major UN donor countries insisted on creating a new coordinating position, an Under Secretary General for Humanitarian Affairs, whose office became one more player to be coordinated. And outside the UN, the International Red Cross and scores of “non-governmental organizations,” often serve as the operating arms for UN agencies and national relief efforts. Rube Goldberg would be proud of this structure.
In a disaster’s immediate aftermath, the biggest problems are logistical: getting food, medicine, shelter and sanitation equipment rapidly to the affected areas, and the most important variables are time and distance. Delegating response to international organizations like the UN, rather than local groups, is a prescription for failure. For those countries that are too poor to have adequate disaster response capabilities, regional organizations like the African Union and ASEAN should be better prepared.
But make no mistake about it: the United States is the default humanitarian world leader because no alternatives are visible well into the future. Who else? The UN? The European Union? The “BRIC” countries — Brazil, Russia, India and China? Forget it. America will take the lead, and we will also take the criticism. Our only grim satisfaction will come if there is an American decline, as some believe inevitable, and many hope for. The rest of the world will miss us when we’re gone.
John Bolton is the former US Ambassador to the United Nations, and author of “Surrender Is Not an Option: Defending America at the UN and Abroad.”
Have a comment on this PostOpinion column? Send it in to LETTERS@NYPOST.COM!
adsonar_placementId=1482038;adsonar_pid=871774;adsonar_ps=-1;adsonar_zw=440;adsonar_zh=225;adsonar_jv='ads.adsonar.com'; Topics Haiti Earthquake European Union Nicolas Sarkozy United Nations UNICEF World Health Organization World Food Programme Saddam Hussein Rube Goldberg African Union ASEAN Football Federation Comments (1) Post Your Comment Report Abuse01/31/2010 7:02 PM
Nothing here anyone can argue with. The media brainwashes people into bad mouthing the US. People on the ground are very appreciative of what our military does in their humanitarian efforts.
You must be logged in to leave comments. Login ι Register
ad_tag("box1","300x600,300x250","script"); PostPics Today in Pictures 52nd annual Grammy Awards show Red-carpet arrivals at the Grammys Week In Photos Lingerie Football: Los Angeles Temptation Team Weekly animals gallery More in photos Click on Each Photo Video More in videos Most Popular read emailed viewed commented 'Love boat' prom scandal School creep's detention haul Rowdy Rex flips Miami fans the bird, could be fined Savage beagles terrorize East End LiLo's 'rent a date' Savage beagles terrorize East End Nursing home cat can predict impending death School creep's detention haul The dirt on 'filthiest' of NY's hotels Rowdy Rex flips Miami fans the bird, could be fined Week In Photos Red Carpet At The Grammy Awards Week's Best Celebrity Photos Photos: Lingerie Bowl 52nd Annual Grammy Awards Show Obama 'hopeful' on NYC terror trial Pols pushed $$ into their do-nothing Qns. charity Mike's bonehead hires ad_tag("box2","300x250","script"); ad_tag("rt_rail_promo","300x100","script"); China's Hummer Buy Delayed Disney Seeks to Sell Miramax Label Toshiba's Net Loss Narrows U.S. Deficit to Hit All-Time High Two Days That Shook Wall Street U.S. Upgrades Defense of Persian Gulf Allies Toyota to Unveil Plan to Fix Millions of Gas Pedals Grammy Style Disasters Record U.S. Deficit Predicted Grammy Red Carpet Grammys go GaGa It's other half time for Chris Heavy metal Grammys goes GaGa Princess Di: I wish I hadn't married into German family Post Sections News: Business Opinion Columnists Local News Sports: Columnists Scores PageSix: Celeb Photos POPWRAP Page Six Magazine Entertainment: TV Movies Music Classifieds: Rentals Jobs Cars Real Estate NY Apartments Multimedia: Photos Video Specials: Contests/Sweepstakes Customer Care Contact Us FAQ Today's Paper Archives Covers Back Issues Reprints Sitemap Help Subscribe Home Delivery Daily Newsletter E-Edition Mobile RSS User Services Advertising/Partners Media Kit Parade Magazine Coupons Can't find what you're looking for? Try searching:NEW YORK POST is a registered trademark of NYP Holdings, Inc.
nypost.com, nypostonline.com, and newyorkpost.com are trademarks of NYP Holdings, Inc.
Copyright 2009 NYP Holdings, Inc. All rights reserved. Privacy | Terms of Use
BF_BB_DATA = null; (function( ){ document.write(''); var sid="75I8P7"; var c=""; var b=""; BF_BB_SCRIPT=document.createElement('script'); BF_BB_SCRIPT.type="text/javascript"; BF_BB_SRC="http://buzzbox.buzzfeed.com/wd/BuzzBox?sid=" + sid + c + b + '&it=1&cb=' + (new Date()).getTime(); setTimeout(function() { document.getElementById('BF_BUZZBOX').appendChild(BF_BB_SCRIPT); BF_BB_SCRIPT.src=BF_BB_SRC; },1); })();Many foreigners disagree. Just days after Haiti’s earthquake, France’s minister for international cooperation, Alain Joyandet, complained about the US effort, notably our military’s control of Haiti’s main airport. Joyandet said that “this is about helping Haiti, not about occupying Haiti.” Fortunately, France’s president, Nicolas Sarkozy, whipped his minister back into line, just in time before Americans started reminding Paris of France’s colonial legacy in Haiti. Nonetheless, Europe, even after several weeks, is far from matching the US response.
Many people ask why, instead of the United States invariably taking on the burden of “first responder” to humanitarian disaster, the United Nations shouldn’t handle the job. Indeed, in the case of Haiti, there were approximately 9,000 UN uniformed peacekeepers already posted there, as well as almost 2,000 civilian UN personnel. Unfortunately, the UN’s performance over the years demonstrates it is not up to the task. In Haiti, even worse, scores of UN personnel died in the earthquake, including Hedi Annabi, the head of the overall UN mission in country.
The UN’s own internal disorganization has long made fast and effective responses almost impossible. Numerous independently governed and administered UN agencies and programs are involved in humanitarian relief efforts, and each marches to its own drummer. UNICEF cares for children and families; the World Health Organization looks after health, sanitation and medicines; the World Food Program distributes food supplies; and the UN High Commissioner for Refugees provides protection and assistance when political or natural disasters cause large numbers of people to cross national borders. The UN Development Program is supposed to be the overall country coordinator of the work of the many agencies involved, but that’s a nearly impossible task.
Then, of course, there’s the long, well-documented history of waste, fraud, corruption and incompetence in UN programs. In Haiti just last week, for example, UN peacekeeping troops from Uruguay were unable to manage the orderly distribution of food (donated from the US, of course) even directly in front of the Port-au-Prince’s now-leveled Presidential Palace. No criticisms, however, from Paris.
The UN system’s dysfunctional performance over the years culminated in dismay over the handling of refugees and displaced persons when Saddam Hussein renewed his persecution of Kurds and Shi’ites after the 1991 Persian Gulf War. Major UN donor countries insisted on creating a new coordinating position, an Under Secretary General for Humanitarian Affairs, whose office became one more player to be coordinated. And outside the UN, the International Red Cross and scores of “non-governmental organizations,” often serve as the operating arms for UN agencies and national relief efforts. Rube Goldberg would be proud of this structure.
In a disaster’s immediate aftermath, the biggest problems are logistical: getting food, medicine, shelter and sanitation equipment rapidly to the affected areas, and the most important variables are time and distance. Delegating response to international organizations like the UN, rather than local groups, is a prescription for failure. For those countries that are too poor to have adequate disaster response capabilities, regional organizations like the African Union and ASEAN should be better prepared.
But make no mistake about it: the United States is the default humanitarian world leader because no alternatives are visible well into the future. Who else? The UN? The European Union? The “BRIC” countries — Brazil, Russia, India and China? Forget it. America will take the lead, and we will also take the criticism. Our only grim satisfaction will come if there is an American decline, as some believe inevitable, and many hope for. The rest of the world will miss us when we’re gone.
John Bolton is the former US Ambassador to the United Nations, and author of “Surrender Is Not an Option: Defending America at the UN and Abroad.”
Have a comment on this PostOpinion column? Send it in to LETTERS@NYPOST.COM!
sports_page quigo_lower 1482096 871776 440 225 * --> Topics Haiti Earthquake European Union Nicolas Sarkozy United Nations UNICEF World Health Organization World Food Programme Saddam Hussein Rube Goldberg African Union ASEAN Football Federation Comments (1) Post Your Comment Report Abuse01/31/2010 7:02 PM
Nothing here anyone can argue with. The media brainwashes people into bad mouthing the US. People on the ground are very appreciative of what our military does in their humanitarian efforts.
You must be logged in to leave comments. Login ι Register
ad_tag("box1","300x600,300x250","script"); PostPics Today in Pictures 52nd annual Grammy Awards show Red-carpet arrivals at the Grammys Week In Photos Lingerie Football: Los Angeles Temptation Team Weekly animals gallery More in photos Click on Each Photo Video More in videos Most Popular read emailed viewed commented 'Love boat' prom scandal School creep's detention haul Rowdy Rex flips Miami fans the bird, could be fined Savage beagles terrorize East End LiLo's 'rent a date' Savage beagles terrorize East End Nursing home cat can predict impending death School creep's detention haul The dirt on 'filthiest' of NY's hotels Rowdy Rex flips Miami fans the bird, could be fined Week In Photos Red Carpet At The Grammy Awards Week's Best Celebrity Photos Photos: Lingerie Bowl 52nd Annual Grammy Awards Show Obama 'hopeful' on NYC terror trial Pols pushed $$ into their do-nothing Qns. charity Mike's bonehead hires ad_tag("box2","300x250","script"); ad_tag("rt_rail_promo","300x100","script"); China's Hummer Buy Delayed Disney Seeks to Sell Miramax Label Toshiba's Net Loss Narrows U.S. Deficit to Hit All-Time High Two Days That Shook Wall Street U.S. Upgrades Defense of Persian Gulf Allies Toyota to Unveil Plan to Fix Millions of Gas Pedals Grammy Style Disasters Record U.S. Deficit Predicted Grammy Red Carpet Grammys go GaGa It's other half time for Chris Heavy metal Grammys goes GaGa Princess Di: I wish I hadn't married into German family Post Sections News: Business Opinion Columnists Local News Sports: Columnists Scores PageSix: Celeb Photos POPWRAP Page Six Magazine Entertainment: TV Movies Music Classifieds: Rentals Jobs Cars Real Estate NY Apartments Multimedia: Photos Video Specials: Contests/Sweepstakes Customer Care Contact Us FAQ Today's Paper Archives Covers Back Issues Reprints Sitemap Help Subscribe Home Delivery Daily Newsletter E-Edition Mobile RSS User Services Advertising/Partners Media Kit Parade Magazine Coupons Can't find what you're looking for? Try searching:NEW YORK POST is a registered trademark of NYP Holdings, Inc.
nypost.com, nypostonline.com, and newyorkpost.com are trademarks of NYP Holdings, Inc.
Copyright 2009 NYP Holdings, Inc. All rights reserved. Privacy | Terms of Use
BF_BB_DATA = null; (function( ){ document.write(''); var sid="75I8P7"; var c=""; var b=""; BF_BB_SCRIPT=document.createElement('script'); BF_BB_SCRIPT.type="text/javascript"; BF_BB_SRC="http://buzzbox.buzzfeed.com/wd/BuzzBox?sid=" + sid + c + b + '&it=1&cb=' + (new Date()).getTime(); setTimeout(function() { document.getElementById('BF_BUZZBOX').appendChild(BF_BB_SCRIPT); BF_BB_SCRIPT.src=BF_BB_SRC; },1); })();01/31/2010 7:02 PM
Nothing here anyone can argue with. The media brainwashes people into bad mouthing the US. People on the ground are very appreciative of what our military does in their humanitarian efforts.
Read Full Article »