Today’s alliance politics, our assessments of the relationships between the U.S. and her allies, lacks cognitive empathy. And without empathy we retreat into caricature: the “Ugly American” on one side, the “sanctimonious free-riding ally” on the other.
The Ugly American has long served as a moral cudgel, conjuring a loud, incurious hegemon, overconfident and underinformed, certain that power justifies preference. And yes, recent interventions by the United States have been poorly calibrated, its polarization has unnerved allies, and its leaders have lurched...